Thursday, March 13, 2025
45.0°F

County still working to justify variance

Keith KINNAIRD<br | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 14 years, 11 months AGO
by Keith KINNAIRD<br
| March 30, 2010 9:00 PM

SANDPOINT — The Bonner County commission roughed out justifications Tuesday for granting a variance to a couple who expanded their home on Lake Pend Oreille without a permit.

Commissioners Lewie Rich and Cornel Rasor conceptually approved the first-ever variance to the county’s floodplain standard in February, but county officials have struggled to draft findings and conclusions that support the decision.

In order to grant the variance to Dwight and Pamela Sheffler, the county has to find that the request meets each of the five criteria found in Bonner County’s land use code.

The criteria include findings that an undue hardship exists because of site characteristics and that the development code would deprive the landowner of rights enjoyed by other landowners in the same zoning district. The county also has to find that the circumstances do not result from the actions of the applicant, grant a special privilege others don’t enjoy or conflict with the public interest.

The county commission directed the Planning Department to draw up the findings, but Clare Marley told commissioners during a hearing on Tuesday that the department was unable to do so.

The department has previously recommended against granting the variance and the Planning & Zoning Commission denied the Sheffler’s variance request because it did not meet all the criteria, a determination that was overruled by the county commission.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency has put the county on notice that it intends to revoke a 5 percent discount 250 Bonner County landowners receive on their flood insurance policies if the commission grants the variance.

Flood insurance policy holders in the county would have started receiving a 10 percent discount in May because of the recent overhaul to Bonner County’s development code, but the variance would thwart that.

Commissioners picked their way through various conditions, with the much of the discussion centering around the hardship, landowner action and public interest questions.

Rasor and Rich argued having to elevate the home or its bottom floor nine-tenths of a foot to keep it out of the floodplain was an obvious hardship. However, Marley advised the board that a hardship can only apply to the land or structure, not a landowners’ pocketbook, according to the county’s rules and court decisions cited by FEMA.

While Commission Chairman Joe Young has been sympathetic to the hardship question, he continued to struggle with conclusions that the Shefflers did nothing to cause the predicament and that exposing policy holders to higher rates was in the public’s best interest.

“We’re overlooking that the applicant created the problem by not getting a site location permit,” said Young, who added that it’s in the public’s interest to receive benefits from the National Flood Insurance Program.

Rasor expressed doubt FEMA would actually penalize the county and countered that easing federal influence on local decisions would benefit the public.

“I’m not sure it’s in the public’s interest to be bullied by FEMA,” Rasor said.

Rich and Rasor ultimately decided to advance their findings and have the Shefflers’ legal counsel, John Finney, collaborate with planning staff to develop additional findings to bolster the variance decision.

Young continued to voice opposition to the variance. He did not vote on Tuesday’s developments because the action did not require a roll-call vote and there was no tie to break since Rasor and Rich were in agreement.

The board is scheduled to further deliberate the matter on April 20.

MORE IMPORTED STORIES

Variance puts county's flood insurance at risk
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 15 years ago
Board balks on variance
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 14 years, 10 months ago
Variance may boost flood insurance rates
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 15 years ago

ARTICLES BY KEITH KINNAIRD<BR

September 30, 2010 9 p.m.

Appeals court rules in cattle truck spill case

SANDPOINT — Idaho’s Court of Appeals is upholding the vacated judgment against a Canadian cattle truck driver accused of spilling a mixture of feces, urine and rainwater on U.S. Highway 95 in Boundary County.

October 21, 2010 9 p.m.

Constitutional amendments on Nov. 2 ballot

SANDPOINT — Idaho voters will get a chance to weigh in on Idaho constitutional amendments concerning funding for the University of Idaho and public airports, hospitals and electrical systems.

May 13, 2010 9 p.m.

Man with child porn arrested by Border Patrol

PORTHILL — A United States citizen was arrested earlier this month after allegedly getting his car stuck while attempting to sneak into Canada with a laptop computer containing child pornography.