Friday, December 05, 2025
32.0°F

Woman fit to proceed in St. Maries murder case

David Cole | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 14 years, 4 months AGO
by David Cole
| August 2, 2011 9:00 PM

ST. MARIES - A doctor has completed a competency examination for a 28-year-old North Idaho woman charged with murdering her uncle, deciding she understands the charges against her and can assist in her own defense.

Melisa R. Bates, who is accused of killing her uncle in May just south of St. Maries, is now scheduled for a preliminary hearing on Aug. 22 in St. Maries before Magistrate Patrick McFadden.

Bates was scheduled for a preliminary hearing on July 25, but her defense lawyer, William Butler, asked for and received more time to prepare.

McFadden will decide at the conclusion of the hearing whether prosecutors have put forward enough evidence to show she probably did do the killing.

Bates is charged with first-degree murder and is being held at theBenewah County jail.

According to court documents, Dr. Daniel Hayes, of Hayden Lake, conducted the evaluation of Bates' fitness to proceed.

Benewah County Prosecutor Douglas Payne said the standard of fitness is low in the state. It was only necessary to show she could both understand the charge against her and help her lawyer in her defense.

Bates is accused of killing Robert D. Marek, 43, at his home eight miles south of St. Maries along Highway 3.

Bates had been staying with Marek. Payne has said Marek was found shot with a handgun and beaten with a metal rod. He also said there was an attempt to dispose of his body by burning it.

In a separate Benewah County murder case, trial dates now have been set for two codefendants from the Plummer stabbing death in April of 37-year-old Antowyn D. Swiney, of Spokane.

Jody A. Miller, 41, now is scheduled for trial on Oct. 3 and Irael S. Kennedy, 21, is scheduled for Oct. 31, both in front of 1st District Court Judge Fred Gibler.

Two other defendants in that case, Stephen R. Milton and Kelly A. Miller, Jody Miller's wife, have pleaded guilty to the charge of accessory to a felony, which is punishable by up to five years in prison, Payne said. They have not been sentenced.

Swiney died of multiple stab wounds in a home in Coeur d'Alene tribal housing in the south portion of Plummer. Swiney had been staying with a girlfriend who owns the home. The girlfriend, Angelita Ashby, was an ex-girlfriend of Jody Miller's.

ARTICLES BY DAVID COLE

March 7, 2015 6 a.m.

Firefighters battle Athol fires

ATHOL — Dry and breezy conditions Friday and a homeowner torching weeds accidentally set in motion a fast-moving wildland fire that burned roughly 50 acres.

August 23, 2014 9 p.m.

Wandering grizzly gets to Glacier

COEUR D’ALENE, Idaho — Ethyl, the 20-year-old wandering female grizzly, has arrived at one of the greatest grizzly bear territories in the world — Glacier National Park.

January 29, 2016 10:28 a.m.

Update: Samuel verdict in

Closing arguments completed Friday morning