Friday, April 11, 2025
52.0°F

Cardio vs. strength training ... or both

Judd Jones | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 13 years, 7 months AGO
by Judd Jones
| August 20, 2011 9:00 PM

From what I can tell this question is right up there with talking politics or religion at work. I have noticed most people have a very firm position on this subject and are willing to debate the finer points to the death.

OK, so which do you really think is better for burning up calories and increasing metabolism: cardio workouts or strength training? The short answer is - and you're not necessarily going to like it - you really need to do both to get all the benefits.

Here is what we know: as you age you lose muscle. "If you don't use it, you lose it." It has also been proven you burn more calories when you do 30 minutes of weight training than when running for 30 minutes, assuming the intensity of the workout is the same. Plus, we know the more cardio you do, the stronger your heart, lungs and endurance becomes.

On the other hand, dieting and aerobic exercise without strength training can cause muscle loss. We also know the more cardio you do and the more muscle you have, the higher your metabolism will be. The higher your metabolism, the more fat your body burns. Whew that was a lot of what we know...

Here are a few basics to understand. Cardio is an "aerobic exercise," running, cycling, and swimming, which require a great deal of oxygen to generate the energy needed for prolonged exercise. Strength training is "anaerobic exercise" and an example of this type of activity is weight training. Basically oxygen is not needed to generate energy from this type of activity.

Both aerobic and anaerobic activities use two energy sources. Your aerobic activities use oxygen, glycogen and fat stores which becomes your energy source.

Anaerobic activities use ATP (adenosine triphosphate) and relies on creatine phosphate and lactic-acid or anaerobic glycolysis that uses glycogen in the absence of oxygen as its energy source.

Both activities burn calories in the form of fat and glycogen stored in the body, liver and muscles.

Here is what I believe formulates four great reasons to incorporate both cardio and strength training into a single fitness regimen:

1. Pro-Cardio: The heart muscle develops more muscular walls making the heart stronger, which in turn allows the heart to becomes more efficient to deliver more blood with less effort. One of the ways to measure positive results is a slower heart rate when resting.

2. Pro-Strength: Muscles and joints become stronger helping injury prevention. This creates a solid foundation by strengthening our bones, ligaments, and tendons. Weight training will help build muscle tissue and slow muscle loss as we age.

3. Pro-Cardio: The heart and lungs become stronger and more efficient at delivering oxygen. Recovery after all exercise is also enhanced. There is increased elasticity of the arteries and it increases the numbers of capillaries within muscles, improving circulation and muscle development.

4. Pro-Strength: Adding muscle increases our metabolism naturally. In turn, this will help improve your body's resting metabolic rate, which we know, will constantly burn fat even at rest. Muscle has a high demand for calories and requires a lot of energy to keep it moving. The more muscle tissue you have, the more calories it needs in order to maintain that muscle.

I am sure we will never get everyone to agree to combining cardio training with strength training, but there is overwhelming research that has shown the collaborative benefits of both cardio and strength training.

It reduces the risk of heart disease, increases bone density, reduces stress, improves sleep and gives you more energy by building a strong overall healthy body. Setting an expectation that "the harder you work your body, the more calories you'll burn, the more muscle you'll tone and build" is your best approach when establishing a cardio and or strength fitness program.

Judd Jones is Regional Production Director for Hagadone Newspapers.

MORE IMPORTED STORIES

Cardio or strength: which do you prefer?
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 10 years, 8 months ago
Cardio training vs. strength training for weight loss
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 8 years, 2 months ago
Fueling your body for activity
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 9 years ago

ARTICLES BY JUDD JONES

December 17, 2016 2:30 p.m.

Bad weather running

Last week I was reading an article in this newspaper that stated we have not seen very many single digit temperatures in the last few years and we have not had subzero temperatures at all in a few years. Global warming aside, here we are looking at a very cold winter ahead and an arctic express on top of us as of today.

December 10, 2016 8 p.m.

Is high intensity cardio bad?

Over the last 10 years, we have seen an explosion in the popularity of high intensity cardio workouts. Millions of people have incorporated everything from basic aerobics to Insanity classes and the once very popular Zumba regimen. Every year, newer and tougher high impact cardio programs tend to make the top fitness trends.

September 10, 2016 9 p.m.

Exercise programs, one more time…

The summer is over, fall will soon be here and it’s a great time to consider a realistic exercise program. There are a few things to consider before you take your first, second or 10th attempt at a fitness regimen. The best programs that can truly deliver excellent benefits to your health often require the least overall impact to your time and body.