Tuesday, January 21, 2025
17.0°F

Plea talks in murder case

Keith Kinnaird News Editor | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 12 years, 6 months AGO
by Keith Kinnaird News Editor
| July 3, 2012 7:00 AM

SANDPOINT — Plea negotiations remain under way for two alleged accomplices in the first-degree murder of Michael Wyatt Smith.

Jennifer Thrasher and Christopher Robin Garlin are charged as accessories in the shooting death of Smith last September. They are accused of withholding knowledge of Smith’s slaying for five months.

Thrasher’s husband, Austin, is accused of shooting Smith in the head and torso with a .357 pistol in the woods near Thrasher’s Cocolalla home.

The killing went undetected until early this year, when all three suspects were apprehended in an unrelated burglary of a Ponderay pawn shop. Garlin and Jennifer Thrasher disclosed knowledge of the killing while in custody in the burglary case, according to court documents.

Smith’s remains were recovered from a makeshift grave north of Sandpoint after the disclosures.

The trio was charged in state court with grand theft and burglary for the Pawn Now break-in, but the cases were dismissed in favor of federal prosecution.

Jennifer Thrasher was to be tried this month on the accessory charge, although her defense counsel is asking for proceedings to be postponed until her federal case is resolved, state court records show.

Garlin, meanwhile, is seeking continuances in his federal case in a bid to resolve all the charges against him, federal court records indicate.

“Mr. Garlin is facing very serious state charges and the parties are working towards a global resolution in both matters,” federal public defender Amy Ruben said in a motion.

Garlin, 18, is scheduled to be tried in the accessory case in December if plea negotiations fail to bear fruit. Jennifer Thrasher, 23, is scheduled to enter a plea in the federal case on July 18, although further hearing dates in her accessory case are pending.

Austin Thrasher, also 19, is scheduled to be tried for Smith’s killing in October.

All three suspects remain jailed while the murder cases are pending.

Although all three defendants were implicated in the Pawn Now heist, only Jennifer and Thrasher are facing charges. There is no record in the federal courts database of charges against Austin Thrasher.

MORE IMPORTED STORIES

Suspect sentenced in burglary case
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 12 years, 2 months ago
Further jail in question in accessory to murder case
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 11 years, 8 months ago
Binding plea agreement sought in murder case
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 12 years, 3 months ago

ARTICLES BY KEITH KINNAIRD NEWS EDITOR

Deputies remain hospitalized
January 19, 2017 midnight

Deputies remain hospitalized

SANDPOINT — Bonner County sheriff’s deputies who were shot in the line of duty on Monday remained hospitalized on Tuesday.

October 19, 2013 10:06 a.m.

Unrelated deaths under investigation

CLARK FORK — Sheriff’s detectives are probing two unrelated deaths that occurred in eastern Bonner County last week.

January 30, 2016 6 a.m.

Highway intersection project OK'd

PRIEST RIVER — The Idaho Transportation Department is gearing up for a intersection improvement project to ease congestion on U.S. Highway 2 and Highway 57.