Common Core putting second graders through the paces
Submitted Duane Pitts | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 12 years, 4 months AGO
National standards are nothing new; they have been in place at least since the 1950s. However, what the Common Core standards are doing to curriculum can best be explained by Nancy Carlsson-Paige of New York in an email to Susan Ohanion:
"What is so fundamentally wrong with this Engage New York approach . . . is the focus on content and having facts and correct answers, a focus that requires a fact-based, didactic pedagogy for success. One where kids passively sit while teachers direct teach content that is irrelevant to them and disconnected from the ways that they learn."
You see, in New York City, the Common Core-based curriculum directs seven-year-olds to learn about the War of 1812.
Could any topic be more developmentally inappropriate for second graders? As Susan Ohanion states it, "Not one American in 100,000 knows what the war was about, and most adults are busy on Social Media, working multiple jobs to pay their mortgage."
Here are just a few of the many Core Content Objectives for the War of 1812 for Grade 2:
Explain that America fought Great Britain for independence
Explain that the Founding Fathers wrote the Constitution
Explain that Thomas Jefferson purchased the Louisiana Territory from the French
Explain that Great Britain became involved in a series of wars against France
Explain that due to a shortage of sailors, Britain began to impress, or capture, American sailors
And so on. Note that the way to make the use of fact after fact "Common Core" is to put "Explain" in the directions.
It is hard to believe that anybody could be serious about inflicting this on second graders. But in our current approach to education reform, this is where we are.
Duane Pitts is a retired English teacher now living in Moses Lake. He taught English for 42 years - eight years in Valdosta, Ga; two years in Colfax; and 32 years in Odessa. As a retiree, he serving as a facilitator by helping teachers and principals learn about the new state teacher-principal evaluation project.
ARTICLES BY SUBMITTED DUANE PITTS
Getting reluctant boys to read
Submitted by Duane Pitts
Our son Joshua used to hate to read. Many boys are like him in that respect - they do not want to read, see no purpose in it, and see no reason to read. However, there is hope for parents with resistant or struggling readers.
Retired teacher explains Common Core State Standards
This school year, you will hear much about Common Core State Standards (CCSS). Basically, it is a set of national standards aimed at making students college and work place ready as well as preparing them to be competitive on the world market. This system began in the 1990s with the National Governors Association, and 45 states adopted the CCSS in order to receive federal money in the Race to the Top program.
Teachers anxious about Common Core reading suggestions
My colleague Marianne Iksic and I realized that though the state standards were superior, the new national standards were here to stay. Between 90 to 95 percent of our English program matched the Common Core State Standards (CCSS).