Critic Souza becomes part of establishment
Chuck Malloy | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 10 years, 1 month AGO
When Mary Souza of Coeur d'Alene begins her first session as a state senator next month, she says she plans to keep her head down, stay quiet and not make waves.
"That will probably last about 15 minutes," she said, laughing.
Souza, who has been a constant thorn in the side of public officials in Coeur d'Alene, hardly fits the profile of "quiet and shy." Her personality is more suited to leaping tall buildings and tearing down trees - in the name of truth, justice and ridding the planet of political corruption.
Two years ago, she spearheaded the unsuccessful effort to recall Mayor Sandi Bloem and three members of the Coeur d'Alene City Council, essentially painting them and Lake City Development Corporation (the city's urban renewal agency) as crooks who were robbing from the taxpayers for the benefit of political cronies. Souza's relentless fury especially was stinging to Bloem, who is more like the Lake City's favorite grandma than Al Capone.
Within the past year or so, Souza experienced defeat and victory in the political arena - getting trounced in a mayor's race, then defeating longtime Sen. John Goedde in last May's Republican primary election. Souza was a clear beneficiary of Idaho's closed primaries, which tends to favor more conservative candidates.
Now this community gadfly steps into a different world. Souza is suddenly part of the political establishment. Complaints and late-night phone calls, which go with the territory of an elected official, will now be directed at her.
The target is on her back, but as Souza sees it, that's nothing new. A person doesn't go after the mayor, three council members and an established agency such as LCDC without getting some bruises along the way. She says her attacks were never meant to be personal and adds that some people who meet her say, "You're actually nice." That's a hard line to swallow for the public officials who have been subjected to Souza's wrath.
Strangely, her critics are not talking openly about Souza going to the Senate. Bloem says she's "the wrong person to ask." Former councilman Mike Kennedy, who was subject to the recall effort, said, "I don't have anything constructive to add to the conversation. As a citizen, I hope she does a good job and I wish her well."
But her history as a conservative activist raises questions about how effective she will be in the Legislature. Politically, she's poles apart from moderate Senate leadership and influential members such as Sen. Dean Cameron of Rupert and Sen. Shawn Keough of Sandpoint. Can Souza work with them? At what point will she be painting moderate colleagues with the same broad brush as Bloem and Kennedy?
What influence will OpenCDA, an organization she helped start, have on her duties as a state senator? That question may be answered fairly soon if there is legislative action related to the Idaho Education Network issue. OpenCDA recently issued a commentary praising Rep. Judy Boyle of Midvale for exposing Gov. Butch Otter administration's role with the illegal $60 million broadband contract.
"Finally!! Finally a state-level elected official in Idaho has the courage to publicly speak out about what many of us have observed for years," the OpenCDA commentary stated. The organization, in which Souza is no longer involved, encourages Souza and others to insist that "corruption in Idaho government be attacked rather than ignored."
Souza agrees that corruption should not be ignored, but the broadband contract will not be her first order of business as a state senator. She says she's going to the Legislature to listen, learn, do a lot of reading and represent her constituents from District 4.
"People will think what they want and I'm not going on a crusade to make them like me," she said. "I didn't run for this office to fill out my resume in life. I feel comfortable with what I've done and who I am. The reason I did this is because real, regular people need to be involved in government."
Souza has plenty of friends going in, including Rep. Kathy Sims (also of District 4) and Rep. Vito Barbieri of Dalton Gardens.
"She's well educated, has a good grasp of the issues," said Sims, who worked with Souza on the recall effort and defends her longtime friend.
"We should not be spending $22 million of taxpayer money [on McEuen Park] without asking them and you should never go into debt without asking for voter approval," Sims said. "People think that because it goes through LCDC, then it's OK. But I don't think it's OK. For them to spend that kind of money on a park, when the food bank is empty, that makes no sense whatsoever. Their priorities were wrong. I totally agree with the recall and I worked on it as hard as she did."
Barbieri thinks Souza will "fit in nicely" in the Senate and work well with the leadership team and some of the more conservative members. "She's personable, analytical and darn intelligent," Barbieri said.
Souza, as with Sims and Barbieri, takes the conservative side on most issues, but bristles at the "tea party" label.
"I'd be happy to take that label if you tell me what it means," she said. "Does it mean I am racist? No, I am not. Does it mean I am radical religious and feel everybody is going to hell? Do I hate kids, hate education, hate development and hate businesses? No."
But if "tea party" means a desire for a smaller government, she said, "OK, I'll take it."
Chuck Malloy is a longtime Idaho journalist who grew up in the Silver Valley. He's now based in Boise.
ARTICLES BY CHUCK MALLOY
Paulette Jordan eyes run against Risch
There’s speculation, with perhaps some wishful thinking among Democrats, that former state Rep. Paulette Jordan will run for the U.S. Senate this year – giving Idahoans at least one competitive high-level race.
Please 'click' on this article and read it
In the life of a newspaper writer, mood swings are common. Turn a couple of good stories for the front page, and it’s a good week. It’s maybe not so good if it’s a week of mundane stories that land deep on the inside pages. I’ve been on both ends during my career.
Lower costs, more cures and who takes credit
President Trump has called on Congress to support efforts to lower the outrageous costs of prescription drugs, and what’s playing out in Congress is the political version of the “Me Too” movement.