A summer reading list on civic education should include Milton's 'Areopagitica'
DAVID ADLER/Guest opinion | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 10 years, 7 months AGO
Summer reading lists abound. They target teens, teachers and toddlers, the sports crowd, the beach crowd and the couch crowd. Everyone touts a list. Bill Gates and Bill Clinton have lists. The American Library Association has a list. The New York City Public Library has a list. National Public Radio has a list. There are even summer reading programs for those interested in civic education, which is a good thing, given the civic literacy deficit that plagues our nation.
Lists that would nurture "civics" should include the masterful work of the 17th Century English poet, John Milton, whose "Areopagitica" represents, in many ways, the cornerstone of the tradition of freedom of speech. Milton's eloquent, unsurpassed plea for freedom of speech, unrestricted by licensing requirements, exerted a great influence on those who framed our First Amendment.
Written in 1644, in the chaos of the English Civil Wars, Areopagitica is a powerful, impassioned, beautifully written pamphlet, which takes dead aim at the practice of prior restraint, a virulent form of censorship that required governmental approval of newspapers, books and essays before they could be published. Milton acknowledged that bad ideas might circulate among the people, and even wield influence, but the proper response was not less, but more speech. Censorship precluded robust discussion and debate, and paved the way for governmental manipulation of knowledge and, ultimately, public opinion.
Milton's memorable argument for the right of the people to publish freely and to energetically engage in debate as a means of correcting heretical ideas and promoting governmental accountability, summoned truth - knowledge, facts and evidence - as an antidote for false doctrines. In a famous passage, Milton wrote: "And though all the winds of doctrine were let loose to play upon the earth, so Truth be in the field, we do injuriously by licensing and prohibiting to misdoubt her strength. Let her and Falsehood grapple; who ever knew Truth put to the worse in a free and open encounter?"
What does Areopagitica say to us today? It reminds those who would compete in the marketplace of ideas, that mere belief is not knowledge, and that for beliefs to prevail in the competition to win the minds of fellow citizens, they must be backed by facts and evidence. It is a reminder, moreover, that in a republic it is persuasion, grounded on reason, and not demagoguery, that deserves respect and victory.
Milton's landmark work, which has informed Supreme Court opinions, including Justice Brandeis' famous warning - "the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people" - reminds us as well that free speech is the remedy for poor, misguided governmental practices and policies. Freedom of speech can expose the poverty of thought that shapes laws and programs. Given protection, speech is an effective tool for the correction of many governmental and societal ills.
Four centuries later, Areopagitica deserves a wide audience. It opens a window into a world in which ideas, based on merit and expressed by rich and poor alike, can wield influence and speak truth to power. It will tutor those interested in the pillars of republicanism, and it ought to be required reading for government officials who may be tempted to use their powers to silence opposition and to prevent challenges to their positions. Members of the Osher Institute and various book clubs will delight in its absorbing narrative. They, like many others, will find it a valuable summer companion to the entertaining and enlightening works of such talented Boise-based writers as Anthony Doerr, Heather Parkinson Dermott and Clay Morgan.
David Adler is the director of the Andrus Center for Public Policy at Boise State University, where he holds appointment as the Andrus Professor of Public Affairs.
ARTICLES BY DAVID ADLER/GUEST OPINION
Ascension of women leaders marked by hurdles, successes
The aspirations of American women to gender equality deserve and require fulfillment if the words and vision of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution are meant to be more than rhetorical vessels.
Ode to the prep class of 2014
As I listened to the precocious, eloquent graduating high school senior explore the nature and styles of leadership at home and abroad, the wheels of my memory raced back to a time of delivering lectures about leaders whose idealism drove them to create a better world. Pericles, an ancient Athenian leader whose transformation of Greek Democracy was so sweeping that it spawned the "Periclean Age," saw conditions that he found unacceptable and proceeded to shape them in accord with his image of the greatest political community the world had ever known.
Ginsburg's remarks reminders of U.S. gender inequality
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's remarks at a law school conference on the U.S. Supreme Court's relative indifference to the rights of women in recent years reflects the checkered historical record of American institutions and businesses on the matter of gender equality. Justice Ginsburg's stirring dissents from recent opinions that have inflicted harsh blows to women's rights in cases involving equal pay, medical leave and contraception, remind us of the long, winding and unfinished road that women have traveled in their march toward equality with men. The court, she said, has never quite embraced "the ability of women to decide for themselves what their destiny will be."