Monday, December 15, 2025
35.0°F

Transfer of public lands would benefit Montana

Sen. Jennifer Fielder | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 11 years, 7 months AGO
by Sen. Jennifer Fielder
| May 10, 2014 11:30 AM

It’s a big idea and it’s rightfully reaping big debate nationwide. Can and should states assume control of federally-held public lands within our borders?     

Many colleagues and experts throughout the West have studied the issue intensively, and we now believe there’s no reason why we can’t. The challenge is to get the facts on the table, put protections in place consistent with Montana values, and prepare our state agencies for an orderly transition.

Montana’s study of public lands shows Montanans want more multiple-use access, reduction of wildfire fuels, and more economic production. But federal agencies systematically continue to do the opposite of what we want.

Shifting to state-based public land ownership would mean Montanans — not Congress, the President or any other state — would decide how much access, use, protection and production we would want to see.

I cannot imagine any collection of people who care about Montana’s communities, environment and economy more than Montanans do. There is no question that 25 million acres of federally-controlled public lands in our state directly impact our land, water, air, wildlife, economy and people in a number of ways. The same cannot be said of states like New York, New Jersey or Florida.

With the national government facing insurmountable debt, the threat of the federal government selling our public lands to the highest bidder is imminent. In fact H.R. 2657, which authorizes the sale of hundreds of thousands of acres, passed out of a Congressional committee earlier this year. They can sell public lands without our input, and they are undoubtedly under pressure by foreign debt holders to do so. That’s a big concern.

On the bright side, a multitude of studies reveal legal standing and economic advantages favoring state-based public land management. Nevada’s most recent analysis shows a net gain up to $1.5 billion per year if they take over management of Bureau of Land Management properties in their state, even while maintaining existing uses such as recreational access, grazing, mineral and other use rights.

With states implementing a responsible balance of protection, use and economic production on forest and rangelands, we could keep public access routes and recreation facilities open for all visitors, reduce wildfire fuels and enhance wildlife habitat. Keeping resource revenues in state could result in millions of new dollars available for local roads, schools, law enforcement, emergency services, utilities, state and local wild land firefighting departments, and other services.

Shifting to state-based management would result in priorities consistent with Montana values. Better access, more jobs, increased funding for public services, protection of our environment and active prevention of catastrophic wildfires could become the rule rather than the exception.

As chairperson of Montana’s Study of Federal Land Management, I continue to assess available information and consider a variety of solutions to correct problems with federal land management. I welcome your comments and questions at www.jenniferfielder.us.

Complete information about transfer of public lands can be found online at www.americanlandscouncil.org.

Sen. Jennifer Fielder, R-Thompson Falls, represents Senate District 7 and is chairperson of the committee for Montana’s Study of Federal Land Management.

ARTICLES BY SEN. JENNIFER FIELDER

December 31, 2014 6:25 a.m.

Charity versus taxation and hope for the New Year

What do you suppose would happen if each of us did more instead of expecting someone else to do all the good things that need to be done? What if we each did all we can do to help ourselves and help others? Charity would become contagious, popular, and ironically, maybe even less necessary.

January 28, 2015 6:12 a.m.

Studying public land transfer next step for Montana

Thanks to passage of Senate Joint Resolution 15 last session, the Montana Legislature conducted an intensive interim study of the problems with federal land management. I sponsored the 2013 legislation and chaired the 2013-2014 study, both of which passed out of committee with broad bipartisan support.

April 13, 2015 6:19 a.m.

Montana should get its 5% share of federal land sales

As a result of Montana’s study of federal land management during the 2013-2014 interim, a wide variety of issues were reviewed. One small detail I noticed is the federal government is not paying their lawful share of proceeds to our state school fund each time Uncle Sam sells public land in Montana.