State asks judge to reconsider broadband ruling
KEVIN RICHERT/Idaho Education News | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 10 years, 2 months AGO
The state is asking a judge to take another look at his decision to void the $60 million Idaho Education Network broadband contract.
In a 12-page motion filed Tuesday, the state's outside counsel is asking District Judge Patrick Owen to either clarify his Nov. 10 ruling to toss out the contract, or reconsider his decision.
Owen said the contract was void when the state cut one contractor from the high school broadband project, Syringa Networks Inc. And because that voided the contract, he said, the state cannot salvage the deal.
That ruling has critical implications, the state's attorneys contend. This leaves the state without a contract "on which to order and run critical wide-area network services for state agencies or under which to operate and fund the education network," Merlyn Clark and Steven Schossberger wrote in the state's motion.
The motion is just the latest legal maneuver in the 5-year-old legal battle over the Idaho Education Network contract. The system now provides broadband to 219 high schools across the state - but with the network still in legal limbo, millions of federally administered dollars for the network remain on hold as well.
The 2014 Legislature gathered $11.4 million to replace these federally administered "e-rate" phone bill surcharges and keep the system in place through February. The 2015 Legislature may need acquire as much as $11.6 million to keep the network online through June 30, 2016.
Tuesday's motion was filed by attorneys for the Boise law firm Hawley, Troxell, Ennis and Hawley, which has represented the state in the legal process. The legal costs to defend the contract are reportedly approaching the $1 million mark, with the taxpayers' share approaching $875,000.
The network's Program Resource Advisory Council, a group of lawmakers and state and school officials which oversees the network, will meet at 9 a.m. Friday in Boise to discuss the latest legal filing.
ARTICLES BY KEVIN RICHERT/IDAHO EDUCATION NEWS
ISAT report card: Opt-outs scarce, few glitches
Eastern Idaho's Madison School District has publicly opted not to use Idaho's new Common Core-aligned tests - but that appears to be an isolated protest.
Teacher pension plan earns high marks
Idaho system has 93.9 percent of liabilities covered
Nationally, teacher pension programs are headed on a downward spiral, toward crisis - but Idaho's system is relatively sound.
State will rebid broadband contract - but when?
The state will rebid its disputed Idaho Education Network broadband contract - but in the meantime, districts may be pursuing their own funding to keep their schools wired.