Wednesday, May 21, 2025
44.0°F

State, school launch probe into mailers

The Associated Press | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 10 years, 7 months AGO
by The Associated Press
| October 23, 2014 7:20 PM

HELENA (AP) — Montana and Stanford University officials launched separate investigations Thursday into official-looking mailers that arrived at Montana homes this week rating how liberal or conservative the four nonpartisan candidates for state Supreme Court are.

The mailers are part of a research project being conducted by the political science faculties of Stanford University and Dartmouth College, but they appear as though they came from the state.

The fliers carry the state seal and the title “2014 Montana General Election Voter Information Guide.” Underneath, it places the judicial candidates on a scale from “More Liberal” to “More Conservative,” with President Barack Obama and former Republican Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney at either end of the scale.

“Take this to the polls!” a line at the bottom of the mailer says.

The fliers, which have shown up in mailboxes in Helena, Missoula, Kalispell and Billings, are deceitful because the seal and the title gives the appearance that they came from Secretary of State Linda McCulloch’s office, McCulloch said.

“This was a piece intended to influence voters,” she said. “I think they actually crossed the line from research into influencing voters.”

Only her office can authorize use of the state seal, she said. McCulloch is working with Commissioner of Political Practices Jonathan Motl to address whether any laws have been broken.

Motl said the mailers’ appearance two weeks before the election, the use of the state seal and the printed directions for voters to take them into voting booths is cause for concern.

“The concern is that it has the appearance of a communication on behalf of the state of Montana when it is not, in fact, a state of Montana communication,” Motl said. “It does not look like a scholarly document.”

The mailers could be considered advocacy, in which case the people behind them must file formal disclosures with his office, Motl said.

Small type on the fliers disclose they were paid for by Stanford and Dartmouth researchers, and direct readers to a Stanford University webpage.

The webpage says the fliers are part of a study “on the impact of information about candidate positioning on turnout and ballot roll-off” in nonpartisan elections.

Stanford spokeswoman Lisa Lapin said the university has started its own inquiry into whether proper research procedures were followed.

“We are taking this very seriously,” she said. “We sincerely apologize to those voters and we apologize to the secretary of state for the confusion.”

The researchers were not available for comment, she said.

Montana judicial elections are nonpartisan, meaning that candidates cannot identify themselves as part of a political party. The rules are meant to ensure an independent judiciary.

Former state solicitor general Lawrence VanDyke is challenging incumbent Justice Mike Wheat, and Billings attorney W. David Herbert is attempting to unseat Justice Jim Rice.

MORE IMPORTED STORIES

State, school launch probes into mailers
The Western News | Updated 10 years, 6 months ago
Apology letter to be issued over election mailers
Daily Inter-Lake | Updated 10 years, 6 months ago
Finding: Scientists broke Montana election laws
Hungry Horse News | Updated 10 years ago

ARTICLES BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

September 9, 2021 12:03 a.m.

The Latest: US helped family escape Afghanistan overland

WASHINGTON — The United States is confirming for the first time that it has helped a U.S. citizen and family members to escape Afghanistan through an overland route to a neighboring country.

September 8, 2021 12:03 a.m.

The Latest: US helped family escape Afghanistan overland

WASHINGTON — The United States is confirming for the first time that it has helped a U.S. citizen and family members to escape Afghanistan through an overland route to a neighboring country.

September 8, 2021 12:03 a.m.

The Latest: Top Republican says Taliban holding Americans

WASHINGTON — The top Republican on the House Foreign Affairs Committee says some Americans who have been trying to get out of Afghanistan since the U.S. military left are sitting in airplanes at an airport ready to leave but the Taliban are not letting them take off.