Wednesday, April 30, 2025
55.0°F

How accurate is Old Farmer's Almanac?

Randy Mann | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 8 years, 8 months AGO
by Randy Mann
| August 29, 2016 9:00 PM

It’s been brought to my attention from a number of weather enthusiasts and readers about the recent prediction from the original Old Farmer’s Almanac. Their winter forecast calls for snowier and milder than normal for us residents in North Idaho and surrounding regions. They also foresee snowy weather for much of the extreme northern U.S. with drier than normal conditions across the rest of the West, most of the central U.S. and parts of the Southeast. This would mean that drought conditions in California will continue.

There is a competing Farmers’ Almanac that is predicting mild and stormy weather for the Northwest for the upcoming winter season. Cliff and I still see snowier than normal conditions across the northern portions of the country, including North Idaho. However, it may be a little colder than average as sea-surface temperatures are cooling down.

I’ve been asked a number of times of my opinion of the Old Farmer’s Almanac and its accuracy. With the new edition recently hitting the newsstands, many have wanted to know if this publication is as “on the money” as their website states an 80 percent accuracy rate. Many forecasters find that number a bit hard to believe and almost impossible to accomplish.

Prior to last year, The Old Farmer’s Almanac forecasts of heavy snows in the Northeast and colder weather worked out pretty well. But, in 2012, the forecast of a frigid and snowy winter did not happen as that season was the fourth warmest on record. And, the Almanac’s outlook for a cold 2015-16 winter season actually turned out to be much warmer than normal across the country.

The Old Farmer’s Almanac claims to use “complicated” mathematical formulas, sunspots, planetary positions and even tidal patterns to forecast the weather. The publication was first developed in 1792 and continues to provide long-range weather outlooks.

With an increasing need for more accurate long-range weather forecasts, many people tend to rely on their information. I have found the perception of those who follow this publication believe it to be fairly accurate. I had many relatives who were farmers and swore to the Almanac’s accuracy. One could only imagine the conversations that went on, but it was all in good fun.

According to a five-year study conducted in the early 1980s by two research meteorologists, John Walsh and David Allen from the University of Illinois at Urbana, the final results of their study differed little from the mere flip of a coin. They pointed out an approximate 51 percent accuracy for temperature and 52 percent correct as far as precipitation was concerned for the Almanac.

Walsh and Allen used 32 cities, two each, from the 16 various forecast regions of the country used by the Old Farmer’s Almanac. Spokane and Miles City, Mont., made the list.

The study showed that the National Weather Service averaged about a 60 percent accuracy rating in “seasonal” outlooks published in advance. The private long-range prognosticators, including our long-range weather service, believe it or not, received the highest accuracy ratings at near 70 percent.

However, whether one considers their forecasts to be highly accurate or not, you have to give them credit. Their annual forecasts, especially the ones for winter, continue to make headlines and the publication has continued to thrive over the years in the media’s ever-changing environments.

•••

In terms of our local weather, August ended up drier than normal with only .66 inches of moisture in Coeur d’Alene as the strong ridge of high pressure held on over the West. Most of the precipitation either stayed to our north or to the east over Montana.

Instead of the rain, a number of brushfires broke out over the region over a week ago. As of last Friday, according to the National Interagency Fire Center, there were 36 active large fires burning across much of the West. Nearly 600,000 acres have burned from these blazes alone. The highest number of wildfires as of last Friday was not California or Washington, but in our own state of Idaho. Last Friday, California had six fires, Washington had seven and Idaho reported nine blazes.

Despite the recent outbreak, about 4.3 million acres have “gone up in smoke” from Jan. 1 through Aug. 26 across the U.S. The figure was much higher for the same time in 2015 as around 7.6 million acres burned. Last year, U.S. wildfires scorched a record 10.12 million acres.

Although we had some days with smoke in our region, the overall summer season seemed to be a pretty good one for 2016. My confidence for early September moisture is still good as the long-range computer models are now showing an increasing chance of rain developing during the normally wet “new moon” lunar cycle of Sept. 1-8.

The middle of September should also bring more showers. October may be drier than normal, but things should start to become more active with rain and perhaps, even some snow starting in early to mid November.

Contact Randy Mann at randy@longrangeweather.com

MORE COLUMNS STORIES

Old Farmer's Almanac gives winter forecast
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 6 years, 7 months ago
Farmer's Almanac says we should see snow
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 3 years, 8 months ago
WEATHER: Source of frustration
Coeur d'Alene Press | Updated 10 years, 5 months ago

ARTICLES BY RANDY MANN

February 19, 2018 midnight

A 'tale of three winters'

As predicted many weeks ago, snow returned to Coeur d’Alene and surrounding regions on Valentine’s Day. Cliff Harris measured 6 inches at his station last Wednesday. It wasn’t a record, but it was close. The snowiest Valentine’s Day occurred in 1949 when 7 inches of snow fell.

Less snow expected for 2018-2019
October 22, 2018 1 a.m.

Less snow expected for 2018-2019

Every year in mid-autumn, Cliff Harris and I issue our annual city-by-city snowfall predictions for North Idaho and surrounding areas of the Inland Empire.

September 19, 2016 9 p.m.

It may be more of a 'La Nada' than a 'La Nina' this fall season

Weather or Not

Last week, I talked about the chances for freezes in the Coeur d’Alene area. Temperatures last Monday and Tuesday dropped into the 30s around the Lake City, but frosts and freezes were reported from Rathdrum and Athol northward. Athol dipped to 31 degrees on Tuesday, Sept. 13. Spirit Lake dropped to a very chilly 27 degrees a day earlier.