OPINION: Fault the speechwriter, not speaker
P. DAVID MYEROWITZ | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 8 years, 5 months AGO
If I am interpreting the Inter Lake’s July 22 editorial correctly, Melania Trump’s plagiarism from Michelle Obama is a mortal sin. She took such unique Michelle Obama thoughts as, “you work hard for what you want in life,” “your word is your bond” and “you treat people with respect.”
Has no one ever used these thoughts in speeches over the millennia? Really? Come on, editorial board, how about doing a little research? And does Michelle Obama, who took one of her thoughts from Saul Alinsky, similarly deserve scorn? Should Obama himself have been publicly humiliated for stealing the words of Deval Patrick, former governor of Massachusetts in 2007? Should Joe Biden for plagiarizing British politician Neil Kinnock in 1998? And I could give four or five other examples of Democratic plagiarism that went unnoticed.
The Inter Lake editorial board points to the severe consequences visited upon a briefly appointed (never elected) Sen. John Walsh, who only achieved that brief title by manipulation of the early retirement of Max Baucus, a scandal unto itself. What the editorial board fails to identify is that Walsh plagiarized an entire page word-for-word from a Harvard paper and that each of his six conclusions was stolen from a Carnegie Endowment for International Peace document and used in a paper written to obtain a master’s degree from the U.S. Army War College without attribution. Also, he did it purposefully. He copied the page word for word with the intent to claim it as his own.
Hardly the same level of transgression as the future first lady having a speechwriter closely paraphrase three or four sentences of a decade old speech, which itself was not very original.
Intent is important. I don’t believe Melania Trump wrote her speech, though she did deliver it well. If anyone is guilty, it would be her speechwriters for not using a plagiarism checker. The woman who claimed guilt was dismissed by the drive-by media as “falling on her sword” (I wonder if they attributed this phrase to Plutarch of ancient Rome, who apparently used it in relation to Brutus).
After all, you can’t sully the Trump campaign by condemning a speechwriter. They needed to degrade an outstanding performance by a beautiful woman to derail the success of the Trump convention. I agree the campaign should have apologized, mentioned that the values spoken of in both speeches need to be shared by all, and moved on.
By being defensive, they stoked the fires of the media (apparently including at least some on our editorial board) to find something — anything — about this intelligent, beautiful, accomplished woman to criticize. She will be the envy of every other first lady in the world when she assumes that role as our first lady.
As one of my mentors used to say (and I hope since I am using an attribution, although blinded, the Inter Lake won’t take me to task), “Envy is a terrible thing ... it eats away at the insides!”
Myerowitz is from Columbia Falls
ARTICLES BY P. DAVID MYEROWITZ
Inter Lake too tough on Zinke?
I am not for wasteful government spending, but does the Daily Inter Lake need to parrot the Associated Press’s repeated assaults on Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke’s air transportation spending ... and putting this garbage on the front page? After the liberal media got rid of HHS secretary Tom Price for using excessive charter flights, I’m sure they figure this is a way to get rid of most of the president’s Cabinet, not that any Democrats ever abused this privilege!
Was Obama team working to undermine Trump transition?
WOW! Can this piece-of-work we call the Congress and the drive-by media be any more pathetically one sided? Can their emphasis on character assassination and process overshadow the truth any more than they have obfuscated the truth thus far?
Creative problem-solving needed in Glacier Park
So Glacier National Park is considering a “one car in, one car out” policy at venues on dead-end roads such as Bowman Lake due to overcrowded parking causing a “safety issue.” I wonder how often emergency vehicles have had a problem getting to where they were needed at the lake. Not to mention that it seems to me a helicopter would be more useful in providing timely intervention and not be affected by overcrowded parking. My guess is that there are fewer than 50 parking spaces (excluding the campground itself) for the whole site, including people parking for multi-day backcountry hiking.