Tuesday, January 21, 2025
17.0°F

Chief justice says ethics board sent him 'letter of inquiry'

Associated Press | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 4 years, 4 months AGO
by Associated Press
| August 27, 2020 12:03 AM

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — The chief justice of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court received an “informal letter of inquiry” on Wednesday from the board that investigates allegations of wrongdoing by judges, his office confirmed.

The probe apparently concerns allegations that Chief Justice Thomas Saylor may have improperly interfered in disciplinary matters involving former Justice Cynthia Baldwin.

Baldwin was recently reprimanded for her actions as Penn State’s top lawyer in representing university administrators nearly a decade ago before a grand jury that was investigating Jerry Sandusky.

“Today, the chief justice received an informal letter of inquiry to which he will respond in due course,” said Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts spokesperson Stacey Witalec. No other details were disclosed.

Baldwin, who is Black, made public in late July a sworn affidavit that accused Saylor, who is white, of complaining to another judge in 2012 about Baldwin's supposed “minority agenda.”

The affidavit by former Northumberland County Judge Barry Feudale, who had managed the Sandusky grand jury, claims Saylor told him at a judicial conference in Hershey that a disciplinary complaint was in the works against Baldwin in connection with the Sandusky investigation.

Saylor told Feudale that Baldwin “caused us a lot of trouble when she was on the Supreme Court with her minority agenda,” Feudale claims in the affidavit.

Saylor has denied that allegation, describing it as false and offensive.

“If the affidavit is as sworn, it shows bias and vindictiveness” in the disciplinary process against her, Baldwin said last month.

Baldwin said she did not know of Feudale's allegations against Saylor until her lawyers in the disciplinary matter received the affidavit from Feudale.

Baldwin, 75, a Democrat, served briefly as a justice in 2006-07 as an appointee of then-Gov. Ed Rendell.

Saylor, 73, a Republican, has been a justice since 1997 and is nearing mandatory retirement age. He recused himself when the Supreme Court voted 4-0 earlier this year to reprimand her because she testified about university officials to an investigating grand jury after she had accompanied them when they testified before the panel.

The state Supreme Court removed Feudale from his role overseeing statewide grand jury investigations in 2013 at the request of the state’s then-attorney general, Kathleen Kane. The high court also declined to reappoint Feudale as a senior county court judge.

Baldwin told The Legal Intelligencer she did not file a judicial ethics complaint against Saylor.

“I went through the whole thing, and when it was over, I still had the affidavit. I said to myself, if you are not part of the solution, you’re part of the problem,” Baldwin told The Legal Intelligencer. “If people don’t know these allegations exist, and you don’t make it public, then you’re part of the problem.”

She told the paper she did not think she and Saylor had any problems while they served together on the Supreme Court — but was shocked to read Feudale’s affidavit.

“I didn’t know of any tensions with the chief justice,” she said. “To me, we were all amicable colleagues. I was shocked. But then after I got over the shock, I was saddened and upset.”

___

This story has been corrected to say Saylor will respond “in due course,” not “in due time.”

MORE IMPORTED STORIES

Chief justice says ethics board sent him 'letter of inquiry'
Columbia Basin Herald | Updated 4 years, 4 months ago
Ex-justice levels bias accusation at state's chief justice
Columbia Basin Herald | Updated 4 years, 6 months ago
Sandusky prosecutor and former Penn State lawyer disciplined
Columbia Basin Herald | Updated 4 years, 11 months ago

ARTICLES BY ASSOCIATED PRESS

August 18, 2021 12:03 a.m.

Hong Kong police arrest 4 from university student union

HONG KONG (AP) — Four members of a Hong Kong university student union were arrested Wednesday for allegedly advocating terrorism by paying tribute to a person who stabbed a police officer and then killed himself, police said.

July 25, 2021 12:09 a.m.

For South Sudan mothers, COVID-19 shook a fragile foundation

JUBA, South Sudan (AP) — Paska Itwari Beda knows hunger all too well. The young mother of five children — all of them under age 10 — sometimes survives on one bowl of porridge a day, and her entire family is lucky to scrape together a single daily meal, even with much of the money Beda makes cleaning offices going toward food. She goes to bed hungry in hopes her children won’t have to work or beg like many others in South Sudan, a country only a decade old and already ripped apart by civil war.

July 24, 2021 12:09 a.m.

For South Sudan mothers, COVID-19 shook a fragile foundation

JUBA, South Sudan (AP) — Paska Itwari Beda knows hunger all too well. The young mother of five children — all of them under age 10 — sometimes survives on one bowl of porridge a day, and her entire family is lucky to scrape together a single daily meal, even with much of the money Beda makes cleaning offices going toward food. She goes to bed hungry in hopes her children won’t have to work or beg like many others in South Sudan, a country only a decade old and already ripped apart by civil war.