Friday, May 09, 2025
64.0°F

Murder suspect committed

KEITH KINNAIRD | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 4 years, 5 months AGO
by KEITH KINNAIRD
News Editor | November 14, 2020 1:00 AM

SANDPOINT — A Coeur d'Alene woman accused of first-degree murder was committed Friday to a state hospital while awaiting trial.

After reviewing a mental health evaluation of Judith Marie Carpenter, 1st District Judge Barbara Buchanan ruled that Carpenter lacked the fitness to proceed in the first-degree murder case and the capacity to make informed decisions about her mental health treatment, according to the commitment order. Buchanan further ruled that Carpenter was "dangerously mentally ill."

Idaho law defines persons as dangerously mentally ill as someone who is in need of supervision and treatment. Such persons also present a substantial risk of physical harm to themselves and others, and to be dangerous to such a degree that a maximum-security treatment setting is required.

Mental health evaluations in Idaho criminal cases are filed under seal, which means only defendants, attorneys and judges are privy to their contents. The evaluations cannot be viewed by the public.

Carpenter's defense counsel, Coeur d'Alene attorney Joseph Sullivan moved for his client's commitment to a Idaho Department of Health & Welfare hospital following mediation that could bring resolution to the criminal case. A psychologist/neuropsychologist met with Carpenter at some point during the mediation and determined that Carpenter lacked the capacity to assist in her own defense due to an unspecified mental disorder.

The prosecution concurred with the defense request after reviewing the doctor's evaluation, court records show.

Carpenter, 59, is accused of shooting Shirley Ann Ramey to death at Ramey's Trestle Creek home on April 5, 2017. The criminal complaint further alleges that Carpenter may have killed Ramey during the attempted commission of a burglary and/or a robbery.

Carpenter was tied to the killing after she was apprehended in Montana during a road rage incident in which a Glock semiautomatic pistol and a lever-action rifle were seized as evidence. The Glock was matched forensically to Ramey's killing and the rifle was determined to have been stolen from the Ramey residence, according to court documents.

Carpenter denied involvement in Ramey's death and pleaded not guilty. She remains held at the Bonner County Jail in lieu of $1 million bail.

Buchanan's order commits Carpenter to a state hospital for up to 90 days for up to 90 days, during which a progress report is prepared and an opinion is rendered as to whether Carpenter is fit to proceed. The order suspends criminal proceedings while the commitment order is in place.

Keith Kinnaird can be reached at kkinnaird@bonnercountydailybee.com or followed on Twitter @KeithDaily Bee

MORE FRONT-PAGE-SLIDER STORIES

IDOC turns away murder suspect
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 4 years, 5 months ago
IDOC turns away murder suspect
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 4 years, 5 months ago
Case against murder suspect expect to proceed
Bonner County Daily Bee | Updated 4 years, 2 months ago

ARTICLES BY KEITH KINNAIRD

March 7, 2010 11 p.m.

Revett seeks clarity on Rock Creek mine status

A status conference is pending in federal court to determine if developers of the proposed Rock Creek mine can initiate development of the project.

December 31, 2008 11 p.m.

Former pastor imprisoned for touching young girl

SANDPOINT, Idaho — A district judge declined to go along with a plea agreement which proposed a limited jail sentence for a former pastor who pleaded guilty to fondling a Priest Lake girl several years ago.

Judge orders life sentence in Bristow murder
April 21, 2021 1 a.m.

Judge orders life sentence in Bristow murder

Acosta ordered to serve life in prison for Bristow killing