Monday, June 09, 2025
90.0°F

State seeks to dismiss Lake County’s lawsuit

KRISTI NIEMEYER | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 2 years, 5 months AGO
by KRISTI NIEMEYER
Kristi Niemeyer is editor of the Lake County Leader. She learned her newspaper licks at the Mission Valley News and honed them at the helm of the Ronan Pioneer and, eventually, as co-editor of the Leader until 1993. She later launched and published Lively Times, a statewide arts and entertainment monthly (she still publishes the digital version), and produced and edited State of the Arts for the Montana Arts Council and Heart to Heart for St. Luke Community Healthcare. Reach her at editor@leaderadvertiser.com or 406-883-4343. | December 14, 2022 11:00 PM

The State of Montana, represented by Crowley Fleck PLLP, responded Dec. 12 to Lake County’s lawsuit seeking reimbursement for costs incurred from Public Law 280 by seeking dismissal of the complaint.

In its 19-page motion, filed Monday in the 20th Judicial District Court, the State maintains that because Lake County consented to participation in the agreement in 1963, and as a result, agreed to its related costs, and because it now has the ability to withdraw from the agreement, articulated in House Bill 656 passed by the Legislature in 2021, the court should dismiss the complaint.

The same legislation says, “the state shall reimburse Lake County for assuming criminal jurisdiction annual to the extent funds are appropriated by the Legislature,” and appropriated $1 from the general fund.

In its appeal for dismissal, attorneys for the state argue that the county does not meet the narrow definition that might allow one government entity to sue another; that the county’s claim of an “unfunded mandate” is contradicted by the county’s consent to participate in Public Law 280 and its newfound ability to withdraw from the agreement.

The state also argues that the county failed to follow administrative procedures in place that allow local governments to challenge “administrative costs of a program, activity, or undertaking required by state law.”

The motion for dismissal maintains that state law places the responsibility for building and maintaining a detention center and providing for its inmates needs, on the county.

The motion also argues that the county’s complaint of “unjust enrichment” should be dismissed because state law prohibits the county from “seeking repayment of funds it consented to incurring.”

Finally, the motion argues that legal precedence prevents “litigants from adjudicating matters in the court that are more appropriately in the domain of the legislative branch.”

MORE NEWS STORIES

Public Law 280: Timeline
Lake County Leader | Updated 2 years, 5 months ago
Judge rules Public Law 280 suit can move forward
Daily Inter-Lake | Updated 2 years, 1 month ago
Judge rules Public Law 280 suit can go forward
Lake County Leader | Updated 2 years ago

ARTICLES BY KRISTI NIEMEYER

June 7, 2025 midnight

Public Law 280 saga winds down with three signatures

Monday marked a quiet end to a long-running saga as the three Lake County commissioners signed a resolution rescinding three previous attempts to remove the county from the responsibilities enshrined in Public Law 280.

Fire season amps up on and off reservation
June 5, 2025 midnight

Fire season amps up on and off reservation

Fire season appears to be amping up earlier than usual in western Montana, with two fire starts last week. Ongoing dry, windy conditions prompted the Confederated Salish & Kootenai Tribes Division of Fire to elevate the danger level from moderate to high on Tuesday.

June 5, 2025 midnight

Filing deadline June 11 for municipal elections

Several seats remain unclaimed with the filing deadline for municipal elections in Polson, Ronan and St. Ignatius next Wednesday. The general election will be held Nov. 4.