Tuesday, June 10, 2025
82.0°F

Effort launched to fight social media ban

CAROLINE LOBSINGER | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 1 year, 11 months AGO
by CAROLINE LOBSINGER
I grew up in the Tri-Cities, Wash., and have always loved to write. I attended the University of Washington, where I earned a double major in journalism and political science, with an area of emphasis in history. I am the fifth out of six kids — don't believe any of the stories that my siblings tell. To be able to tell others stories and take photos for a living is a dream come true — and I considered myself blessed to be a community journalist. When I am not working, I enjoy spending time with family and friends, hiking and spending time outdoors, genealogy, reading, and watching the UW Huskies and the Seattle Seahawks. I am a servant to my cat, Frankie, who yes, will eat anything and everything in sight … even wedding cookies. | July 6, 2023 1:00 AM

SANDPOINT — A GoFundMe campaign has been launched to cover a likely legal challenge by those being blocked on social media accounts by District 1 Sen. Scott Herndon.

The challenge is expected to be filed in late August, said Alicia Abbott, one of those who were blocked by Herndon.

The campaign, which was launched June 21, would create a litigation fund to cover the challenge to their First Amendment rights, organizer Alicia Abbott said.

"There are likely dozens of us at this point, and it is time to do something about it," she said.

The campaign, "Help Idahoans Blocked by Senator Scott Herndon," seeks to raise $10,000 to fight the bans.

Abbott said the move seems to be part of a trend among some legislators to block any comments or questions with which they disagree. That includes, she said, asking their stance on extreme groups or views, which appears to be what triggered her ban by Herndon.

She had criticized the state senator for his stance on various issues and his affiliation with far-right groups and individuals, including Dave Reilly, who many believe runs the anonymous Idaho Tribune propaganda website.

"What’s really funny, I've been going back and forth with Scott Herndon on social media for over a decade and I’ve said a lot worse things in that time," she said.

However, Herndon contends that his social media accounts are connected to his campaign and are not official sites. As a result, he said he can block those he feels violate his social media policy. Most of the bans, a majority of which are on Twitter, are due to profanity, name-calling, or "label lynching, with terms like Nazi or fascist" among the most frequent, Herndon said.

"I welcome opposing view points on my pages as long as people conduct themselves civilly by abiding by the linked policy," he told the Daily Bee.

The policy notes the pages are for Herndon to communicate with District 1 residents regarding legation and policies. Any comments that aren't related to that communication or contain "fighting words," graphic or gratuitous violence, vulgar language or profanity are subject to being removed. Also prohibited are comments determined to "threaten, intimidate, harass, or defame any person or organization."

In a mid-June email, Abbott told Herndon that the ban violated her free speech rights and called on him to unban her immediately.

"You and your office have embraced social media as a crucial means of communicating and interacting with your constituents and the public," she wrote. "As your constituent, I was once able to use your social media platform to have my views heard directly by you and your staff ... That was until I was blocked from your official Twitter account."

Others who were barred from the social media accounts said Herndon claimed he blocked them over a lack of civility. However, they contend that is an excuse to bar anyone who pushes back on his views or his narrative.

"He claims that he is against echo chambers, but is very liberal with the block button when it comes to people disagreeing with his posts," said one.

Abbot said the bans are prohibited by both the Idaho and U.S. constitutions. She also noted that recent court decisions ruled that public officials' social media accounts are public forums and subject to the First Amendment. In Knight v. Trump, a federal circuit court ruled that former President Donald J. Trump's Twitter page was a public forum and ruled he had violated the amendment when he blocked people.

"You, like the former President, are the public official, who has created the public forum and blocked me from it, thus violating the Idaho and United States constitutions," she wrote. "You may not do this. You may not prevent me from engaging in the comment threads on your public social media page."

ARTICLES BY CAROLINE LOBSINGER

FBCHS graduates told to 'stay curious'
June 10, 2025 1 a.m.

FBCHS graduates told to 'stay curious'

Armed with curiosity, literary wisdom and unshakable resilience, 29 Forrest Bird Charter School graduates received their diplomas Saturday, ready to tackle whatever the world throws at them.

'Be bold and audacious'
June 8, 2025 1 a.m.

'Be bold and audacious'

Sandpoint High's Class of 2025 ready to thrive

As they stood on the edge of their next adventure, Sandpoint High School's Class of 2025 was celebrated at Friday's graduation ceremony.

LPOHS graduation celebrates strength, perseverance
June 7, 2025 1 a.m.

LPOHS graduation celebrates strength, perseverance

Grads honored with tributes, personal gifts

Each of the 23 Lake Pend Oreille High School graduates was celebrated at a commencement ceremony Thursday that was both personal and celebratory.