Royal City talks insurance at council meeting
JOEL MARTIN | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 2 years AGO
City Finance Director Shilo Christensen discusses insurance options with the Royal City City Council. From left: Shilo Christensen, Council Member Michael Christensen, Council Member Perla Garcia, Mayor Kent Anderson, Council Member Hector Rodriguez and Council Member Tiffany Workinger.
Joel Martin
Joel Martin has been with the Columbia Basin Herald for more than 25 years in a variety of roles and is the most-tenured employee in the building. Martin is a married father of eight and enjoys spending time with his children and his wife, Christina. He is passionate about the paper’s mission of informing the people of the Columbia Basin because he knows it is important to record the history of the communities the publication serves. | May 10, 2023 1:20 AM
ROYAL CITY — Insurance was a significant topic at the Royal City City Council meeting May 2.
The first order of business involved the city’s co-sponsorship agreement with Summerfest. The draft agreement called for Summerfest to indemnify the city in case someone gets hurt at the town’s community celebration, which takes place July 7-8. Summerfest, which operates as a nonprofit corporation, does not currently carry liability insurance because of the cost, council members said.
“The liability piece for the city is, it's an event that you're co-sponsoring, but you're not the ones in charge of the event,” explained City Attorney Katherine Kenison. “Your staff isn't involved in setting up the event, putting the event on, being on site during the event and managing it. So to the extent there was an accident, somebody got injured, you don't have a lot of control over that … if the city is sponsoring the event, then your choices are either have each party remain responsible for its own negligence, in which case, yes, you would want Summerfest to have insurance to back up that indemnity. Or you can agree that the city, in co-sponsoring it, assumes the liability and not require insurance. So obviously (there is) a lot more risk for the city if you don't require anything from Summerfest.”
If the city is willing to increase its exposure in the event of an injury, said Finance Director Shilo Christensen, the council could just strike out the indemnification clause.
“I wouldn't have a problem doing that,” said Council Member Tiffany Workinger. “I know that the bounce houses and that type of stuff, they all carry their own insurance. So if somebody were to hurt themselves on those, those people carry insurance.”
“Well, they do carry insurance,” Kenison said. “But the way that Washington liability laws work … because it's your property, and because you're sponsoring the event, even though the bounce house owner and operator is supposed to have L&I licenses and insurance to cover liability, you're never going to not be named in the lawsuit. Because it's your property, your event.”
“So you're saying the bounce house insurance company is going to go after the city?” asked Workinger. “So in the same conversation, the city's mitigating their liability by holding Summerfest responsible. But wouldn't then whoever is suing still go to the biggest pocket, which is the city? The same way that they're going to override the bounce house insurance, they're going to override Summerfest insurance and put that on the city?”
“Washington (has) joint several liability,” Kenison explained. “If both the city and the bounce house owner are sued, then the plaintiff can collect against either party. So if we were 10% liable, and the bounce house owner was 90% liable, the client can collect 100% from us. And then it's up to us to go after the bounce house owner to the 90%. And if they're under-insured, you're not going to recover that.”
“So really, there's probably no negative from just carrying it ourselves anyway and taking that out,” Mayor Kent Anderson said. “Because we're going to be liable anyway, if something happens.”
“As property owner and co-sponsor, you're going to be named in (a lawsuit),” Kennison replied. “It's just a matter of whose pocket the money is coming out of first.”
The council voted unanimously to remove the indemnification clause.
The question of the city’s insurance pool was raised next. Christensen said the city currently buys its insurance through Cities Insurance Association of Washington, but CIAW’s annual rate has increased significantly, from $132,233.30 in 2022 to $175,485.26 in 2023. Christensen said he had also spoken with representatives from Risk Management Service Agency, which is part of the Association of Washington Cities, and from Washington Cities Insurance Authority. RMSA quoted $122,692 for the year, while WCIA quoted $101,623. WCIA’s coverage also appeared to be better, Christensen added.
“It seemed like (WCIA’s) coverage was even beefier,” he said. “CIAW’s was, I think, $10 million per occurrence, and then WCA was $20 million. They had a lot more ammo.”
“I've worked with all three pools with my different cities over the years and my opinion is that WCIA has provided superior service for their clients consistently over the years,” Kenison said. She explained that CIAW had gone from just insuring cities to insuring other entities like school districts, tribes and homeowners associations.
“They've expanded their pool of clients and so there's a lot more risk,” she said. “I think it's more difficult to manage that risk across that broad spectrum. Because school districts have their own set of statutes, port districts have their own set of statutes, cities have their own set of statutes. So you have to be really good at a lot of things to provide services.”
A final decision won’t have to be made until September, Christensen said.
Joel Martin can be reached via email at jmartin@columbiabasinherald.com.
ARTICLES BY JOEL MARTIN
Newhouse reintroduces Farm Workforce Modernization Act
WASHINGTON, D.C. — A bipartisan bill to make hiring and retaining foreign farm workers more feasible was introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives May 7 by Reps. Dan Newhouse, R-WA, and Zoe Lofgren, D-CA. The Farm Workforce Modernization Act of 2025 would establish a new category for foreign nationals living in the U.S. and working on farms and ranches. To qualify as a certified agricultural worker, or CAW, an immigrant would have to have worked in the U.S. for at least 180 days in the last two years and be inadmissible or deportable but be under a grant of deferred departure or hold temporary protected status, according to a fact sheet from Newhouse’s office. A CAW’s spouse and children could also be eligible to remain in the U.S. as certified agricultural dependents. A CAW would be eligible to work in the U.S. year-round, unlike seasonal workers admitted under the H2-A visa program. “In the past few years, we’ve seen labor shortages contribute to high food prices. If it wasn’t obvious before, the pandemic made clear that our country’s agricultural workforce rules are in dire need of reform,” Lofgren wrote in a statement. “The men and women who work America’s farms feed the nation. The Farm Workforce Modernization Act stabilizes the workforce, which will protect the future of our farms and our food supply. It’s well past time we get this legislation that serves the best interests of our country to the president’s desk.”
Loans, grants help a new generation of farmers take the field
SPOKANE VALLEY — As many as a third of farmers in the United States are over the age of 65, according to a study by the University of Minnesota’s Center for Farm Financial Management. Many of these have family members to pass their farms on to, but in order for American agriculture to continue, a new generation of farmers is needed. The U.S. Department of Agriculture has assistance available for beginning farmers or those who are returning to the field after an absence, according to an announcement from the USDA. The USDA’s Farm Service Agency offers farm ownership and farm operating loans to farmers and ranchers who have trouble obtaining commercial credit from a bank, according to the announcement. “Farming and ranching is a capital-intensive business and FSA is committed to helping producers start and maintain their agricultural operations,” Geremy Nelson, FSA Acting State Executive Director in Washington, wrote in the announcement. “FSA loans are designed to make sure that everyone has access to credit. Last year, FSA in Washington obligated $32.9 million in loans to beginning farmers and ranchers.”
Boys & Girls Club to offer free summer meals
MOSES LAKE — The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Columbia Basin will be offering breakfast and lunch for children again this summer. And this time, they’re offering it in more places. “We’re doubling our location sites,” said Cecily Hendricks, director of operations for the club. Breakfast and lunch will be served at the McGraw Clubhouse and North and Midway elementary schools, according to an announcement from the club. Lunch only will be served at Lakeview, Maple Grove and Doolittle parks. They’re free to any child 2-18 years old; there’s no need to be a Club member, the announcement said. Parents can pick up meals for their children by filling out a form. Because Moses Lake qualifies as rural, the meals don’t have to be eaten onsite.