The story of the United Methodist Church in Superior began in the fall of 1913.

During a train layover, Methodist Deaconess Isabelle Reeves discovered that there was no Protestant church in the area. Inspired to take action, she returned to Chicago and began raising funds to establish the first Protestant house of worship in Mineral County, a Methodist church.

In 1915, the church was built on land donated by Chas and Veronica Harmon. The church bell and first organ were shipped from Chicago by Miss Reeves. That same year, with the local school building not yet completed, the newly built church also served as the classroom for the area's first high school subjects.

By 1950, major remodeling was carried out under the leadership of the Rev. John Ginter. Although the exterior remained largely the same until 2001, this renovation relocated the large stained-glass window originally at the front of the building to the front of the sanctuary.

In 1986, during a summer “fix-up” project, church members discovered a hidden gem while repainting the church bell. For over 73 years, this bell had signaled the beginning of worship services. Beneath layers of paint, volunteers uncovered an inscription:

Isabelle Reeves First Licensed Deaconess in America and the World Licensed June 4th, 1889

Three years later, in 1989, five new stained-glass windows were added to the sanctuary just in time for Easter. These stunning windows were designed and handcrafted by Superior’s own Gerald “Doc” Kay, who donated his time and talent. The windows, celebrating the church’s 75th anniversary, depict themes of Christmas, Easter, Pentecost, the Last Supper, and the Cross and Lamb. They remain a beautiful tribute to both the faith and the community.

In 2001, a major accessibility upgrade was completed. A new bell tower was constructed as part of a project that added a lift serving all three levels of the building. These improvements helped ensure that the church doors are truly open to all who wish to enter.

“This summer, we are planning another important “fixer upper” project which is repainting the exterior of the church,” shared Elaine Robinson, Secretary. “To preserve this cherished historic building, we’ve hired a professional painter, and we are reaching out to the United Methodist Church community and local businesses for support. Any and all donations are deeply appreciated. We extend our heartfelt thanks to everyone who has supported, and continues to support, our church and its mission.” 

Robinson continues, “As Easter approaches, we reflect with gratitude on the many sunrise services we've shared in this beautiful valley. Despite the chill and occasional cloud cover, these moments have been a blessing. This year, we invite everyone to a special Good Friday service at Superior UMC, 7 p.m. on April 18.” 

Easter Sunday Services will be at 9 a.m. in Alberton and 11 a.m. in Superior.

    The Superior Methodist Church in 1950. (Photo provided by Elaine Robinson)