Sunday, December 21, 2025
30.0°F

Study: Idaho renters face 'impossible choices'

CAROLYN BOSTICK | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 5 months AGO
by CAROLYN BOSTICK
Carolyn Bostick has worked for the Coeur d’Alene Press since June 2023. She covers Shoshone County and Coeur d'Alene. Carolyn previously worked in Utica, New York at the Observer-Dispatch for almost seven years before briefly working at The Inquirer and Mirror in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Since she moved to the Pacific Northwest from upstate New York in 2021, she's performed with the Spokane Shakespeare Society for three summers. | July 18, 2025 1:07 AM

The widening gap between wages and rental prices is a rising concern in a new report from the National Low-Income Housing Coalition and the Idaho Asset Building Network.  

The report found that renters in 38 of Idaho’s 44 counties do not earn enough to afford a modest home at fair market rent.  

Panhandle Area Housing Alliance Executive Director Maggie Lyons said her main takeaway from the Out of Reach 2025 rental report is the increasing inability of residents in the workforce who are unable to keep up with the rising rate of rent and other costs.  

“We still have struggling households to be able to put a roof over their heads,” Lyons said.   

Full-time workers need to earn $27.83 per hour to afford a two-bedroom home in Idaho, but the average renter makes $18.81 per hour, the report found.

There are 19,203 renter households in Kootenai County and 191,681 renter households across the state. 

“This year’s Out of Reach report shows that, despite economic gains for some, low-income renters continue to face impossible choices between paying rent and meeting basic needs,” said National Low-Income Housing Coalition president and CEO Renee Willis. 

Affordable rentals in the Coeur d'Alene area are tough to find. A two-bedroom home is being offered at $1,455; a three-bedroom townhouse was listed at $1,750, while another two-bedroom home was going for $2,800.

According to renthop.com, the average rent for an apartment in Kootenai County is $1,595. That's about 50% of the income for someone earning $18.81 an hour.

Willis said cutting federal housing investments would only deepen the crisis and called upon Congress to protect and expand housing programs that ensure stability, opportunity and a pathway out of poverty for renters. 

Rent is supposed to be 30% of a worker’s paycheck, but she said many people in the local population have had to find new work that pays more or drastically cut back to make the numbers work.  

What they’re forced to give up often includes essentials like health care visits, medications, more healthy food and day care.  

Over the course of about five years, the area median income went from $65,500 to $72,000 and then $80,000. Today, the area median income is $97,500.

Making that math work for one worker is extremely difficult, which is why the majority of people PAHA works with are two-income earners. 

“The cost of housing combined with child care and other costs have really, really hurt the low to middle income households,” Lyons said. 

For many that use HUD Section 8 housing to keep their household afloat, she suggests the family self-sufficiency program as the rare government program that incentivizes workers to make more money at work, rather than cutting them off if they make $1,000 or $2,000 more than the bare minimum to survive on. 

“They aren’t penalized for getting a raise,” Lyons said. 

She pointed to Charity Reimagined and Christmas for All as the boots on the ground to ensure that workers stay stable and housed when the worst case scenario occurs. 

“Through Charity Reimagined we are helping shore up housing because costs are taking too much of a bite out of their budgets. We are helping so many people who are working,” Lyons said.   

For additional information, go to http://www.nlihc.org/oor.

ARTICLES BY CAROLYN BOSTICK

Remembering Kent Butler
December 20, 2025 1:20 p.m.

Remembering Kent Butler

Fernan Village man died when tree fell on home during windstorm

In the wake of his death during the height of the windstorm Wednesday, Kent's partner and friends of Kent Butler remember him through kindness he shared and the music he made.

Bayview residents seek dock resolution
December 20, 2025 1 a.m.

Bayview residents seek dock resolution

Lease termination triggers Jan. 1

Bayview residents got an early start on making their voices heard ahead of the termination of the Bayview docks lease scheduled to go into effect Jan. 1 during a Waterways Advisory Committee meeting Thursday. “The county commissioners get meeting minutes and a monthly meeting that’s usually attended by four to five people is suddenly full,” Committee Chairman Doug Harris said.

Falling tree kills man, knocks out power to 80K
December 18, 2025 1 a.m.

Falling tree kills man, knocks out power to 80K

At height of storm more than 80,000 were without power

The Wednesday morning windstorm that caused mass power outages for more than 80,000 households across North Idaho and Eastern Washington also led to the death of a Fernan Village man at a residence on Theis Drive.