Flathead’s water quality can’t afford rollbacks
Mayre Flowers | Daily Inter-Lake | UPDATED 8 months AGO
Each time our local leaders — whether the Flathead City-County Board of Health or the county commissioners — navigate changes to environmental regulations, they must answer one foundational question: "Does this action increase the protection of water quality in the Flathead Basin, or does it add to the cumulative negative impacts that scientific reports warn we must reverse?"
Recently, our county commissioners took a step backward. By adopting a resolution to allow gravity-fed septic drain fields in place of the more protective Uniform Pressure Distribution systems, they chose a path that is factually and scientifically unsupported.
The science is settled, even if the policy isn't: The Flathead-Stillwater Watershed Restoration Plan is not just a "study" to be filed away; it is a roadmap for the survival of our watershed. It documents a historical lack of progress in meeting nutrient reduction mandates and identifies septic leachate as a primary driver of the degradation of Flathead Lake.
The logic used to justify these recent rollbacks — that "this one change isn't that bad " —is a dangerous fallacy. Our water quality is not lost in one single event; it dies by a thousand cuts. Uniform Pressure Distribution is a proven tool that maximizes soil treatment by distributing effluent evenly. In contrast, gravity systems create "hot spots" of saturation that allow nitrogen and phosphorus to bypass treatment and head straight for our groundwater and lakes.
Protecting our unique environment: It is important to remember why Uniform Pressure Distribution became the standard here in the first place. These systems have been required in Flathead County since 2004. They were adopted specifically to address the unique character of our landscape, which features more surface water and shallow groundwater than any other county in Montana. In a region defined by its water, using the most effective treatment technology is not a "luxury" — it is a baseline requirement for environmental safety.
Individual benefits vs. collective property rights: In these discussions, we often hear about the "property rights" of a single landowner to build as cheaply as possible. However, we must recognize a fundamental truth: making decisions that benefit the perceived property rights of a few often harms the property rights of the majority. When a substandard septic system allows nutrients to leach into the groundwater, it doesn't stay on that one person's property. It migrates, potentially contaminating a neighbor's well or degrading the lake that supports the property values of the entire community. Protecting our collective property rights requires a standard of care that ensures one person's "savings" do not become everyone else's liability.
Short-term savings, long-term debt: The commissioners have justified these changes by citing concerns over higher costs for young families and individual homeowners. However, this is a "false economy." While a gravity system might save a few thousand dollars during installation, it risks millions in future taxpayer-funded cleanup costs.
As mandated by the WRP and state standards, we are required to protect and restore these waters. If we allow cheaper, inferior systems now, we are simply offloading the massive cost of environmental restoration onto the next generation. True fiscal responsibility means investing in the "optimum method" of treatment today to avoid a public-funded crisis tomorrow.
A crisis of governance: This policy shift also places the professional staff of our health department in an untenable position. Their mandate is to protect public health and water quality based on science. By stating that these rollbacks were adopted in part because of costs to families, the commissioners are implying that they expect such financial considerations to be given additional weight in the Department’s decision-making process.
By being pressured to give this additional consideration to "cheaper" systems, our professional sanitarians are being asked to prioritize political expediency over their professional duty to safeguard the Flathead’s most priceless resource.
A call to action: We urge the Board of Health to return to a thorough review of these policy changes. We need a revised policy that strictly limits gravity-fed systems and requires failed systems to be replaced with UPDS and Level II treatment—especially in areas draining to impaired water bodies or high-risk zones identified by the 2023 Onsite Wastewater Risk Analysis.
Our elected officials have a duty to be fully informed by the science already at their fingertips. We simply cannot afford to allow decisions that ignore the documented, cumulative harm to our basin. It is time to prioritize the permanent protection and restoration of our water over short-term gains. Sound decision-making must begin with a single, non-negotiable question: 'Does this action increase the protection of water quality in the Flathead Basin, or does it add to the cumulative negative impacts that scientific reports warn we must reverse?'
Marye Flowers is director of Citizens for a Better Flathead.