ADVERTISING - ADVERTORIAL: What causes families to fight over an estate — and how to keep the peace

If you want your estate plan to do more than just transfer assets — if you want it to preserve the relationships you spent a lifetime building — it helps to understand what actually triggers these fights and how thoughtful drafting in an estate plan can prevent them.

What Families Actually Fight About

The disputes I see fall into a handful of recurring patterns:

Surprise. A child learns only after a parent’s death that a sibling is getting more, or that Mom left the house to a second spouse instead of the kids, or that the family business is going to one heir and not another. Surprise breeds suspicion. Suspicion breeds litigation.

Perceived unfairness. Equal isn't always fair, and fair isn't always equal. But when one child gets more without explanation, the others tend to assume undue influence, manipulation, or favoritism — even when none existed.

The wrong person in charge. Naming one sibling as executor or trustee over another can create resentment, especially when that person controls distributions, timelines, or the sale of sentimental property. Most multi-child families do select one of their children to be in charge, but if the others weren’t aware of this choice ahead of time, that often leads to issues. And selecting the oldest child just because he or she is the oldest child is rarely a good approach. The personalities, availability, geographic proximity, and quality of relationships between siblings are all factors that should be considered. In some families the best option is to use someone outside of the family altogether.

Personal property. Strange as it sounds, the biggest fights can be over the smallest items. Grandma’s wedding ring. Grandpa’s shotgun. The Christmas ornaments. These objects carry memory and meaning that dollar values can't capture.

Ambiguity. Vague language, outdated documents, and missing instructions force heirs to guess what you wanted — and they almost never agree with each other when they guess.

How to Keep Fighting to a Minimum

Talk to your family while you're alive. This is the single most effective thing you can do. A family meeting — or even individual conversations — to explain your plan and your reasoning removes the element of surprise and lets you address concerns directly. People may not like the choices that you’ve made, but they will know that they really were your choices, and they will have had a chance to say anything to you they think you ought to know. Those conversations can’t happen after your death or permanent incapacitation, and that can add to the grief and frustration that already exists.

Document your reasoning. If you're treating children differently, say why in a letter of explanation kept with your estate plan. If you've already given one child substantial lifetime gifts, note it. If a child has special needs or financial struggles, explain how the structure protects them. Your voice on the page makes a difference. However, talk to your attorney about any such letter of explanation. It is important that the letter not be structured in such a way that it can be used to change any outcome in your actual estate planning documents. Your attorney can guide you on this.

Choose your fiduciary carefully — and consider a neutral one. The best executor or trustee isn't always the oldest child or the one who lives closest. It's the one with the temperament, organization, and family standing to handle the role without inflaming tensions. For families with significant conflict, a professional or corporate trustee can be worth every penny.

Address personal property specifically. Idaho allows a separate written list of tangible personal property that can be referenced in your will and updated without re-executing the document. Use it. Better yet, talk with your family about who wants what and set up your written list based on those conversations.

Keep your documents current. A plan that hasn't been reviewed in fifteen years — that still names a deceased sibling as executor or leaves assets to an ex-spouse — invites disputes. Review your plan after every major life event and at least every three to five years.

Work with an experienced attorney. DIY documents and online forms produce ambiguity, the single biggest driver of estate litigation. A well-drafted plan anticipates the conflicts your family is most likely to have and addresses them before they start. Your family is not a cookie – don’t take a cookie cutter approach to something this important.

The Real Goal

The point of estate planning isn't just to move property from one generation to the next. It's to do so in a way that honors the relationships that mattered most to you. Done well, your plan becomes one last act of care — not a wedge that drives your family apart.

My law firm is currently offering free telephonic, electronic, or in-person consultations concerning probating estates or creating estate planning documents.

• • •

Robert J. Green is an Elder Law, Trust, Estate, & Guardianship Attorney and the owner of Kootenai Law Group, PLLC in Coeur d’Alene. If you have questions about estate planning, probates, wills, trusts, powers of attorney, guardianships, Medicaid planning, or VA Benefit planning, contact Kootenai Law at 208-765-6555, [email protected], or visit www.KootenaiLaw.com.

This has been presented as general information and not as legal advice. Do not engage in legal decision-making without the advice of a competent attorney after discussion of your specific circumstances.