Monday, November 16, 2026
39.0°F

Big Sky boondoggle

MARK MEYER | Whitefish Pilot | UPDATED 6 months, 2 weeks AGO
by MARK MEYER
| May 6, 2026 12:00 AM

The Big Sky Passenger Rail Authority (BSPRA) is an arm of Montana state government attempting to reinstate rail passenger service in Southern Montana. While they frequently claim progress toward this goal, they never mention that Amtrak currently has no equipment for service expansion, and that any new equipment for long-distance service is eight or more years in the future, still awaiting a design and selection of a manufacturer.  They also never mention that in 2024, a Federal Railroad Administration study of reinstating a once-daily passenger train between Chicago and Seattle through Southern Montana would cost about $3.7 billion.  

In an attempt to show they care about existing Amtrak service in Northern Montana (even though they won’t allow counties along that route to join their coalition), the BSPRA along with Amtrak submitted a request for infrastructure improvement along the Empire Builder route at and near Malta:  “The $18.6 million project addresses two specific bottlenecks in the Malta-to-Glasgow region: a new center crossover at Malta station that eliminates a dangerous reverse-switching maneuver, and an extension of the Bowdoin siding from 8,106 feet to 16,000 feet. Both changes reduce the cascading delays that ripple across the entire Empire Builder route — from Chicago to Seattle/Portland — every time trains are forced to wait.” 

Touted by the BSPRA as an infrastructure win, it is, in reality, an $18.6 million boondoggle solution searching for a problem - BNSF and Amtrak would pay a small percentage of the cost, but most would be borne by the federal taxpayer. Bowdoin is a curious point for a siding extension simply because three other sidings between Glasgow and Havre are shorter. At Malta, the alleged “dangerous reverse-switching maneuver” is, in actual railroad terminology, a meet: A simple, safe, commonplace .3-mile backup move over the west siding switch after one train has done its station work leaving the track clear for the second train to access the station. Backup movements by plan occur daily throughout the country, including in Chicago, Tampa, and Denver. The consist of the westbound Empire Builder needs to be turned on arrival in Portland, Oregon to be facing the opposite way for its eastbound departure later in the day. When it is known that turning the train might be an issue in Portland, Amtrak and BNSF will sometimes elect to turning the westbound train in Vancouver, Washington; the train then backs ten miles through the busy Portland/Vancouver terminal knowing that this is completely safe procedure. As for the “cascading delays” resulting from a meet at Malta (or anywhere else): This is a myth. The current schedule has more than enough schedule padding to recover from any delay. 

So how often do Amtrak trains meet at Malta?  Well, in 2025, they met there only seven percent of the time.  If on time, trains are scheduled to meet in the siding at Wagner, nine miles west of Malta, but due largely to decaying Amtrak equipment (30 to 50 years old), delays are common. In 2025, Amtrak trains through Malta were on time less than 40% of the time. And then there’s the obvious question for Amtrak and the BSPRA even if the trains ran on time: What happens when Amtrak changes the schedule and the meet isn’t even close to Malta? To summarize: The multi-million dollar crossover at Malta will rarely be used, will be a perpetual maintenance expense for BNSF, and will not in itself benefit BNSF freight operations. 

Having already received $500,000 for a current study, the BSPRA continues to lobby for $11 million in federal taxpayer dollars for the second phase of a study of its desired Chicago-Seattle train.  Given the boondoggle about to unfold in Malta, Montanans rightly should question whether the railroading operations expertise of the BSPRA has the standing to be the stewards of taxpayer dollars or to represent the needs of those in Northern Montana along the Empire Builder route. 

Mark Meyer of Portland, Oregon, is a Cut Bank native who had a 40-year career with Burlington Northern and BNSF in railroad operations, including 17 years as a train dispatcher overseeing rail traffic at Malta, Montana.