Monday, November 16, 2026
39.0°F

Rediscovering home: Arguments against Funke's closed hearing

Bruce Moats | Valley Press-Mineral Independent | UPDATED 6 months, 2 weeks AGO
by Bruce Moats
| May 6, 2026 12:00 AM

Adult league basketball and elections are two places where normally sane folks lose it. To be fair, people are and should be passionate about elections.

The court scheduled the hearing involving Mineral County Sheriff Ryan Funke on May 13, with the anticipation of a decision before the June 2 primary election. The court will rule after the evidentiary hearing whether allegations of misconduct by the sheriff while a deputy in Lake County years ago must be provided to defense counsel in future cases where Funke is a witness. 

The judge understood the importance of his decision to the voters, but felt he had to close the hearing to protect so-called criminal justice information. 

A reporter for the Missoulian has written an email asking the court to open the hearing to the public. Andy Tallman makes a good argument: 

 “[T]he Montana Constitution does not have an exception for criminal justice information. The rationale in this context for sealing otherwise public records is when individual privacy is implicated or when disclosure may impede the operation of government. Neither of those apply here. The demands for Funke’s privacy aren’t in conflict with the public right to know, as Funke’s defense counsel has personally told me he’d support the unsealing of these records (and even if he didn’t, the Supreme Court has ruled that a police officer has a diminished right of privacy over records of misconduct), and Funke maintains there’s no incriminating information in these records. . . 

 “This matter is of heightened public interest because Funke is up for reelection as sheriff and this matter is absolutely a large factor in people’s decisions on who to vote for as sheriff. Montana’s public information laws exist to make sure that government operates in full transparency, allowing people to make informed decisions on who to vote for.” 

I agree with Tallman that while it is good that the decision will be public, it is not sufficient. Closing the hearing allows for speculation and rumor to flourish during the heat of an election.  Those who view their side lost in the case will be free to throw about accusations regarding the conduct of the hearing.  

Frankly, the matter is a little difficult to categorize. There is no criminal case here, but the decision could affect the prosecution of future criminal cases in which Funke is a witness.   

The Montana Constitution guarantees: "No person shall be deprived of the right to examine documents or to observe the deliberations of all public bodies or agencies of state government... except in cases in which the demand of individual privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure." Mont. Const. art. II, § 9. The Court has “made clear that [Montana Statute 46-11-701] codifies the constitutional balancing required between the public's right to know and a defendant's right to a fair trial governs the closure of proceedings in criminal cases. “ 

The criminal cases apparently involved in the internal investigation of Funke at issue here took place about a decade ago and are presumably closed.  There can be no prejudice to their cases.  

Unfortunately, Tallman’s plea will likely fall on deaf ears. In my experience, judges will not rule on emails or letters but require motions.  

I traveled to Casper, Wyoming, for a pretrial hearing in a murder trial, after sending the judge a letter asking for a portion of the hearing to be open. The judge called me forward to the bar and matter-of-factly told me: “I got your letter. Send me a motion. You’re excused.” 

If I was drafting a motion, I might suggest that alternatives to closure to protect any countervailing interests might include use of initials or only closing a portion of the hearing. 

However, unless the parties move to open the hearing, it seems likely the doors to the courtroom on the top floor of the Mineral County Courthouse on May 13 will remain closed.