Tuesday, November 17, 2026
34.0°F

Accused child killer appears in court; more horrific details revealed

The Western News | UPDATED 4 days AGO
| November 13, 2026 7:00 AM

A Rexford woman accused of killing her 3-year-old niece earlier this year made her initial appearance in Lincoln County Justice Court Tuesday afternoon in front of Judge Jay Sheffield.

Tina Marie Mergenthaler, 57, is charged in Lincoln County with one felony count of deliberate homicide, one felony count of witness tampering and one felony count of evidence tampering.

The defendant heard the charges against her and Sheffield explained her Constitutional rights to her. The judge ordered that Mergenthaler have no contact with witnesses, victims or anyone associated with the case.

County attorney Marcia Boris sought bail of $5 million, arguing Mergenthaler was a flight risk due to her leaving the jurisdiction and not having contact with anyone for three months. Boris also cited what she termed the horrific nature of the offenses and the witness tampering accusation.

Mergenthaler seemed a bit dumbstruck when Boris sought a $5 million bail. Sheffield, who ordered no bond when he signed the arrest warrant, didn’t make any changes.

The defendant said she understood the proceedings. When Judge Sheffield asked Mergenthaler if she would hire an attorney or have one appointed to her by the state Office of the Public Defender (OPD), she said she couldn’t afford one.

She explained that she was staying in a homeless shelter in Missoula when she was arrested and she didn’t have a permanent address. Mergenthaler also asked if a conflict attorney would be appointed to her and Sheffield said it was up to OPD. He instructed her how to contact the office to find legal representation.

A conflict attorney may be appointed for a client who is indigent, meaning someone who is living in extreme poverty.

Mergenthaler was arrested Monday morning in Missoula and jailed there until being brought back to Lincoln County for her court hearing. She is currently in the county lockup, according to jail records. Those records indicate she has a pending theft charge in another county.

Investigators from the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office, including the since deceased deputy Ryan Terpsma, Montana State Crime Lab, Flathead County Sheriff’s Office and Montana Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation (DCI) worked together in painstaking fashion to assemble the case that spanned three months, along with help from Oregon officials.

Charging documents paint a disturbing picture of chronic abuse and neglect, alleged threats to the deceased girl’s brothers, an attempted cleanup of the crime scene and multiple attempts to deceive law enforcement officers investigating the alleged offense.

After the lengthy investigation, recent developments opened the door for charges to be filed. Those developments included extremely disturbing testimony from the little girl’s brothers, age 5 and age 12, who were in the home at the time and witnessed the alleged homicide.

Monday, Nov. 2, DCI agents Cynthia Lengyel and Alesha Woodland met with one of the brothers at the Oregon Department of Human Services Child Care Center in Klamath Falls.

The 5-year-old child didn’t want to talk about his time in Montana, but he did ask where his aunt, Mergenthaler, was. He did express his worry and the difficulty in speaking about what happened in Montana. 

The child also said he told his foster mother what happened. The agents then spoke to the woman and learned the 5-year-old was in her care since Aug. 11, three days after the alleged homicide.

The woman told investigators after she returned home from a recent trip to a correctional facility to visit another child in her care, the boy asked her if his aunt was going to be arrested. The woman said she wasn’t aware of it.

A few moments later, the child returned to his foster mother and said, “She really needs to be arrested.” The woman asked why and he said, “because she killed my sister.”

The next day, the older brother was interviewed by Agent Woodland on Nov. 3 at a youth center in Eugene, Oregon. When she asked him how his little sister died, he didn’t respond and continued to play with his Legos.

He told the agent that, “it’s too scary to talk about,” and that he witnessed Mergenthaler allegedly choking the child to death while she said, “I want you to die.”

The oldest brother also said he heard his little sister screaming after Mergenthaler took her to the bathroom after the child dropped the woman’s phone and it cracked. He also said Mergenthaler threatened to choke his younger brother.

Law enforcement received evidence results Nov. 3 from the Montana State Crime Lab that opened the door to charges being filed. Evidence analysis typically takes months due to the volume submitted to the lab.

DCI Agent Cynthia Lengyel received a report that indicated a piece of wood trim seized during a Sept. 3 warrant search contained blood, hair and fibers. The charging document also said a DNA report from the crime lab was forthcoming.

According to the affidavit, law enforcement wasn’t able to contact Mergenthaler since Aug. 11, three days after the alleged crime. They reported she abandoned all of her property at a Pinkham Creek area residence. Also, no family members or church members had seen her since Aug. 11.

Aug. 10, county detectives Dan Holskey and Brandon Holzer, along with county coroner Craig Riddle, attended the deceased child’s exam in Missoula. The medical examiner (ME) was confident the girls’ injuries were not due to a fall. The ME also reported seeing a tread imprint on the toddler’s head and he determined the manner of death to be homicide.

On the day of the child’s death, deputies were concerned that her injuries were not consistent with a 4- to 5-feet fall from a tree. They reported seeing multiple contusions to her face, body and chest.

On Sept. 1, the detectives went to the Pinkham Road property following a request by the landowner. They saw towels that appeared to have bleach stains. Two days later, officers returned with an evidence collection team from Flathead County. Trace evidence not visible to the naked eye was seen after a chemical was applied that illuminates when in contact with human blood.

Oct. 16, DCI Agent Lengyel and county Det. Dan Holskey met with state Crime Lab medical examiner, Dr. Civan Altunkaynak. He reported extensive brain bleeding, a broken upper jaw, external healing kidney scars that were multiple weeks old and several rib fractures at different stages of healing.

The investigation began at about 12:42 p.m. Saturday, Aug. 8 when county deputies Scott Welchons and Terpsma responded to a Pinkham Creek Road residence in Rexford after a 911 call indicated a juvenile female had fallen from a tree.

Deputy Terpsma found the accused performing chest compressions on the toddler. She was on the sink counter in the bathroom with only her underwear on. When he and Welchons took over CPR, Mergenthaler allegedly said the girl, “must have hit her head or something…she was knocked out and not breathing so I came in, got her here and started breathing for her…you want to take over, my arms are really tired.”

But, according to a statement from the oldest brother, he said he didn’t see the defendant perform CPR after police told her to do it. He also said she pretended to do it.

In a medical report from Dr. Margaret Satchell, the medical director for the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit at One Sky Health Kalispell Medical Center, she noted that when Mergenthaler was told of the child’s death the defendant responded that the girl, “got under her skin.”

Also, in a digital communication with the landlord of the property where the alleged incident took place, Mergenthaler said there was a serious family emergency and she was planning on leaving at the end of the week. The defendant allegedly told the landlord to keep the information to herself.

A conviction for deliberate homicide is punishable by life, death or a state prison term for a minimum of 10 years or more than life.

Convictions on each of the tampering charges are punishable by a maximum term of 10 years in state prison as well as fines up to $60,000.

To report child abuse or neglect, contact Child and Family Services of the state Department of Public Health and Human Services at 1-866-820-5437. Victims of sexual violence can call the National Sexual Assault Telephone Hotline at 800-656-4673.