Friday, November 20, 2026
30.0°F

Shoshone County Fire District consolidation complete despite petition efforts

JOSH McDONALD | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 1 year, 1 month AGO
by JOSH McDONALD
Staff Writer | October 10, 2025 1:00 AM

A last-minute attempt to halt the consolidation of Shoshone County’s two fire districts failed, making the merger official Monday.

The newly formed Silver Valley Fire Rescue (SVFR) was approved by both districts early last month, triggering a 30-day window for residents to file a petition of objection. Under Idaho law, a public vote on a proposed fire district consolidation can be forced if a petition is signed by at least 25% of qualified electors within one of the districts.

The petition must also be submitted to the fire district—something that reportedly did not occur.

It remains unclear how many signatures were collected, but SVFR Chief Scott Dietrich estimated about 1,200 were needed. Shoshone County Elections Clerk Savanna Willer confirmed there were not enough signatures from Shoshone County voters, and the number of signatures from Kootenai County voters is unknown.

Because the petition was not submitted to the fire district as required, SVFR’s legal team advised the former district boards to proceed with finalizing the merger and determining the composition of the new board.

“After the boards determined that the petition did not fulfill the statute requirements outlined in House Bill 208, they both voted unanimously to proceed with the consolidation of the districts,” Dietrich said.

The board elected Sam Gibbons as chairman. Current board members John Specht, Tyler Carrico, Dennis O’Brien, Mike Pierce and Jeff Passer will continue serving until the May election, when voters will elect representatives for five newly created subdistricts.

The subdistricts, based on ZIP codes, are:

  • Subdistrict 1: Silverton (83867) and Wallace (83873)
  • Subdistrict 2: Osburn (83849)
  • Subdistrict 3: Kellogg/Wardner (83837)
  • Subdistrict 4: Pinehurst (83850) and Smelterville (83868)
  • Subdistrict 5: Medimont (83842), Cataldo (83810) and Kingston (83839)

Opposition to the merger came primarily from residents in District 2, on Shoshone County’s west end, where residents will see a 9% increase in their annual levy rate. District 1 residents will see a 13% decrease.

Many opponents mistakenly believed the consolidation would raise taxes by 9%, which fueled the petition effort.

Gibbons addressed the confusion on social media.

“The petition states that this consolidation will raise property taxes for folks that live in District 2 by 9%. Actually, this will not raise property taxes by 9%. It will raise property taxes for folks that live in District 2 by .9%,” he said.

He clarified the impact on homeowners:

“You're confusing the tax increase with the levy rate,” Gibbons said. “The levy rate will go up 8.6%. A $100,000 home in Kellogg will see an $8.65 annual increase. A $350,000 home will see a $30.27 increase. A $500,000 home will see a $43.25 increase.”

Dietrich verified those figures and addressed another rumor, that the two bonds passed in 2017 and 2018 to build new firehouses would be merged. He confirmed on Wednesday that this is false.

In 2018, voters approved a 30-year, $2.9 million bond for a new firehouse in Kellogg and renovations to the Pinehurst station. In 2017, voters approved a 30-year, $1.9 million bond for a new firehouse in Osburn. Each district will continue to pay off its respective bond.


ARTICLES BY JOSH MCDONALD