Friday, November 20, 2026
32.0°F

Close assessor race remains in limbo after recount cancellation

JOSH McDONALD | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 29 minutes AGO
by JOSH McDONALD
Staff Writer | November 20, 2026 1:00 AM

WALLACE – A scheduled recount in the race for the open Shoshone County assessor's seat has been canceled after state officials determined the recount application submitted by Republican candidate Robert Savage was incomplete. 

Following the Nov. 3 general election, Democrat Katie Murray led Savage by 17 votes, 2,296 votes to 2,279. 

The recount, which Savage requested Nov. 13, had been scheduled for Friday morning in Shoshone County District Court. 

On Wednesday, Shoshone County Clerk Lori Osterberg released a statement explaining the cancellation. 

"The Office of the Idaho Attorney General has advised the Shoshone County Clerk that not all required elements of the recount application were received," the release said. "As a result, the application is considered incomplete under Idaho Code 34-2302, and the recount cannot proceed as scheduled." 

The referenced section of Idaho law requires a candidate seeking a recount to specify which precinct or precincts should be recounted. The application must be submitted to the attorney general or county clerk, and the applicant must pay a $100 fee for each precinct included in the request. 

Idaho law allows candidates 20 days from the date election results are canvassed to request a recount. Shoshone County's canvass was held Nov. 10. 

On Thursday, Savage released a prepared statement outlining concerns he said prompted his recount request and indicating he intends to seek a recount again. 

As of press time Thursday, it was unknown whether a revised recount application had been formally submitted. 

In his statement, Savage said some ballots may not have been counted because voters reportedly marked party designations rather than the designated voting ovals. 

"For example, at one Shoshone County polling location alone, at least 10 ballots were reportedly marked by shading the party designation, such as '(REP)' or '(DEM),' beside a candidate's name instead of filling in the (⬭) voting oval," Savage said. "Those votes reportedly were not included in the election count." 

Savage cited Idaho statutes addressing voter intent and questioned whether some voters, particularly elderly voters, may have been confused by the ballot's layout. 

"The ballot places voting ovals with parentheses before candidates' names and party designations in parentheses after their names," Savage said. "Ballot instructions also depict a filled oval between parentheses. Could this visual similarity have confused voters, particularly elderly citizens with declining eyesight, and should ballots marked this way receive an individual review under Idaho's voter-intent laws?" 

He also questioned whether ballots marked by shading only a party designation should receive additional scrutiny. 

"If a voter shaded only one candidate's party designation without making a conflicting selection, shouldn't that ballot receive an individual review to determine whether the voter's intent is legally recognizable?" Savage said. 

Savage acknowledged that Idaho law requires voters to mark the designated voting area but argued that voter-intent statutes should be considered when evaluating ballots. 

"I recognize that Idaho law requires voters to mark the designated voting area," he said. "However, I also believe the laws addressing voter intent deserve careful consideration when an otherwise identifiable selection is questioned." 

Savage said he was not alleging misconduct by election officials. 

"This is not about favoring any candidate or political party," he said. "I appreciate our election workers and accuse no one of wrongdoing. I simply believe transparency, consistency, and verification are essential to maintaining public trust." 

He also called on county election officials and state officials to explain how such ballots were evaluated under Idaho law and applicable voter-intent standards. 

"I urge Shoshone County election officials and the State Offices to explain how these ballots were evaluated under Idaho law and the applicable voter-intent standards," Savage said. 

Savage added that he would accept the outcome if a recount confirms the election results. 

"If a recount confirms the original results, I will respect them," he said. 

Under Idaho law, a recount is conducted by election officials in the precincts identified in a candidate's petition. Ballots are secured, reviewed in public view and retabulated, with candidates or their representatives permitted to observe the process. The number of ballots reviewed depends on the number of precincts included in the recount request. 

Shoshone County has 14 precincts. Murray won eight of them compared to six for Savage. However, Savage posted large margins in Pinehurst and Kingston, helping offset Murray's strong performances in the absentee, Osburn and Wallace precincts. Murray also carried Kellogg, the county's largest precinct, by three votes. 

ARTICLES BY JOSH MCDONALD