Housing symposium maps out challenges, solutions and resources
KELSEY EVANS | Hagadone News Network | UPDATED 2 days AGO
A housing symposium hosted by the Whitefish Chamber of Commerce, Housing Whitefish and Explore Whitefish last week embraced a realistic but positive spin on a crisis-level challenge as it mapped out solutions and resources.
The reality is those who have the least are struggling the most, said Daniel Sidder, executive director of Housing Whitefish.
"We have entry level workers, seniors and single-parent households that are really burying the burden of increased costs," he said. "Low- and middle-income earners are hanging on by a thread."
Most Whitefish workers, 60 to 70%, commute to work. The median home price is about 10 times greater than the median annual income.
A 2023 survey conducted by the chamber and Housing Whitefish found that 80% of respondents had trouble recruiting and retaining employees.
Displacement and gentrification are problems, Sidder said. He said he continually points to the fact that there are enough bedrooms and housing units in the community; it's just a mismatch of uses.
"Some of you might be thinking, just let the market do its thing. Cut the rules, cut the regs and let the free market work its magic. In fact, there is a growing body of evidence in the housing world that increasing market rate supply in communities can bring more affordable prices ... but in Whitefish, I don't think supply alone is going to save us.
"That's where government and nonprofits step in and fill the gaps."
Rachel Smalley, system director of human resources operations at One Sky Health, formally Logan Health, talked about what the company is doing for employee housing.
"To be honest, we don't have this all figured out. But I can share what's helping us navigate the headwinds," she said.
She said there are three things that are helping with housing challenges: recruiting from outside of the Flathead Valley, focusing on talking about housing upfront with candidates, and working toward retaining their workforce.
One Sky Health also has a housing connect website page for current and future employees in addition to offering guidance to new or tranistional hires.
Erica Wirtala, public affairs director at the Northwest Montana Association of Realtors, said they have 1,350 Realtors in the organization.
She said Realtors are the second most powerful lobbying organization in the country, and that the Road to Housing Act passed this year looks to promote housing supply nationwide.
"That's my dose of optimism for you," Wirtala said. "It was the first comprehensive federal effort."
A portion of the act addresses corporate home ownership.
"I think that will be very hard to enforce for my Realtors," she said. "Someone comes to my realtor and wants to buy a house. You don't know who they're representing."
Still, she said that a lot of burden is being placed on state and local governments to do the heavy lifting.
At the state level, the Montana Land Use Policy Acthas flipped planning on its head and will guide development, she said.
Dana Meeker, Whitefish city manager, said that the 2025 Housing Needs Assessment helped guide the development of Vision Whitefish 2045, the city's new growth policy mandated by MLUPA.
The housing assessment found that Whitefish needs at least 930 new units by 2035 including 342 homes and 588 rentals.
"Vision Whitefish 2045 has set clear direction for us," Meeker said. "The plan calls for diversity of housing types integrated throughout the city. It recognizes the need to serve all demographic groups with a particular emphasis on the workforce. It also introduces an important concept – residents should be able to move in, move up or age in place."
The city of Whitefish has committed more than $5.9 million toward community housing thus far. Funding has come from resort tax revenues, the city's property tax housing levy, tax increment financing and general fund reserves.
Major investments include $500,000 for Habitat for Humanity land purchases for four townhomes, up to $2.97 million for the 22-unit Depot Park Townhomes project, and $1 million for Housing Whitefish's Alpenglow II development. The city has also committed $950,000 over four years to the Whitefish Workforce Rental Assistance Program. Additional support includes a $30,000 housing levy grant to Housing Whitefish for management of Legacy Homes and $480,000 for Northwest Montana Community Land Trust's Trailview Homes project.
The city recently launched a housing dashboard to track its progress on the effort. The dashboard is available at engagewhitefish.com.
Rather than be overwhelmed by the challenges, focus can be turned to "doing the next easiest thing," Sidder said. "Thinking about what you can do at your business, in your community. What's the next easiest think you can do that can make a big impact?"
He said there's a growing number of resources in Whitefish.
"I think that Whitefish has enough resouces, expertise and people that can make our programs run. Our best solutions are going to come locally."
Here are some of the resources available in Flathead County:
Federal resouces are managed locally by the Whitefish Housing Authority and are generally for individuals with the lowest income. Over four counties, Lincoln, Sanders, Flathead and Lake, there are 419 choice vouchers. There is also public housing like Mountain View Manors, and USDA loans, although neither of those are growing in numbers. There is also the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) that incentivizes private developers to build affordable housing.
Housing Whitefish has rental assistance programs and rental units. Since its start in 2024, the Whitefish workforce rental assistance program has served over 150 households, 300 people and 100 children for about $526,000. Housing Whitefish is also, as of Monday, opening applications for the new Big Mountain workforce rental assistance program, which will serve rent burdened individuals who work on Big Mountain but live outside of Whitefish.
Housing Whitefish is also overseeing rental units through the city's Legacy Homes Program, which provides incentives for developers to include affordable units. There are at least 85 units at 93/40 and as off of Edgewood, Colorado and Texas Avenues.
Across Flathead County, the Community Action Partnership of Northwest Montana provides choice vouchers, along with low-income energy assistance, weatherization services, home repair programs and emergency assistance.
Habitat for Humanity focuses on helping households earning between 30% and 80% of area median income achieve homeownership with current projects in Whitefish, Columbia Falls and Kalispell.
NeighborWorks Montana provides financial education, lending programs, resident ownership support and matched savings opportunities designed to help residents build financial stability and pursue homeownership.
The Northwest Montana Community Land Trust creates permanently affordable homeownership opportunities for low- and moderate-income families earning up to 140% of area median income.
For residents facing housing insecurity, The Samaritan House operates a homeless shelter and transitional living program that includes case management services.
ARTICLES BY KELSEY EVANS
Whitefish speech and debate takes second at Hamilton
Whitefish High School turned in a strong performance at the Hamilton Speech and Debate Tournament on Nov. 14, finishing second in the team sweepstakes behind host Hamilton and ahead of Columbia Falls.
Planning Commission looks to add stepback regulation to downtown
The Whitefish Planning Commission on Thursday will review requests to reestablish building stepbacks alongside recommendations for maximum building widths as a means to limit the development of buildings up to 60 feet tall in the downtown area. The commission will also review a zoning request near JP Road which may pave the way for suburban growth in accordance with the recently adopted growth policy.
Housing symposium maps out challenges, solutions and resources
A housing symposium hosted by the Whitefish Chamber of Commerce, Housing Whitefish and Explore Whitefish last week embraced a realistic but positive spin on a crisis-level challenge as it mapped out solutions and resources.